If you’ve ever tried to split Thanksgiving between two families while also keeping your sanity intact, you already know: holidays are less like “quality time” and more like a high-stakes scheduling puzzle. Now imagine one side of the family insisting the puzzle only has one correct answer—them. That’s the reality for a growing number of couples who say their parents expect them to show up for every major holiday, every year, because it’s “only fair.”
The phrase sounds reasonable at first, almost wholesome. Of course parents made sacrifices. Of course adult kids feel gratitude. But when gratitude turns into a permanent calendar claim, it stops feeling like love and starts feeling like obligation with a side of guilt.
The “Only Fair” Argument: Where It Comes From
Parents who lean on the “we raised you” line usually aren’t trying to be villains. For many, it’s shorthand for a deeper feeling: “We miss you,” “We’re scared of being replaced,” or “We don’t know how to be a family if you’re not here.” Sometimes it’s also a generational script—holidays were non-negotiable when they were young, so they assume it should stay that way.
But “fair” is a tricky word. In family dynamics, it often doesn’t mean equitable—it means familiar. If a parent is used to being the default holiday destination, any change can feel like rejection, even when it’s simply the natural evolution of adult life.
Why This Hits Hard Once You’re Married (or Seriously Partnered)
The tension usually spikes when a partner enters the picture. Suddenly it’s not one adult child juggling schedules; it’s a new family unit trying to build traditions of its own. And that can feel threatening to parents who are used to being at the center of every celebration.
There’s also the basic math problem: two families, one holiday. If one set of parents expects “every holiday,” the other set effectively gets none, and the couple gets zero downtime. At that point, it’s not even a family tradition—it’s a monopoly.
The Hidden Cost: Resentment, Burnout, and Awkward Car Rides
On paper, showing up is easier than arguing. In practice, it tends to rack up quiet resentment—toward the parents making demands, toward the partner who feels dragged along, and toward yourself for not speaking up sooner. It can also turn holidays into something you “get through” instead of something you enjoy.
Therapists often describe this as the “price of admission” problem. If the price of seeing your parents is surrendering every holiday, every year, that’s not connection—it’s a contract you didn’t agree to. And nobody wants to spend Christmas feeling like they’re paying off emotional debt.
What Fairness Actually Looks Like in Real Life
Fair doesn’t mean identical. It means considerate, sustainable, and respectful of everyone involved—including you and your partner. A fair arrangement might be alternating holidays, rotating yearly, splitting the day, or traveling less and hosting more.
It can also mean acknowledging that adulthood changes the equation. Your parents raised you, yes. But raising a child is a responsibility you choose, not a tab that comes due in December.
When Gratitude Gets Used as Leverage
There’s a difference between appreciation and obligation. Appreciation sounds like, “We’d love to see you if you can make it.” Obligation sounds like, “After everything we’ve done, you owe us.” The second one tends to land like a wet sweater: heavy, uncomfortable, and hard to take off.
And leverage doesn’t always show up as anger. Sometimes it’s sadness, sighs, “jokes” about being abandoned, or a dramatic “Well, I guess we’ll be alone.” It’s subtle, but it has a clear message: your choices are responsible for their feelings.
A Couple’s Problem That Needs a Couple’s Plan
The most successful holiday negotiations usually start privately, between partners, before anyone calls their parents. What do you actually want your holidays to feel like? How much travel is realistic? What traditions matter, and which ones are just habits you’ve never questioned?
Once you’ve agreed on a plan, the key is presenting it as a united decision, not a debate your parents can enter. If one partner becomes the “bad guy,” it creates a pressure point parents can push on for years. It’s not about being cold—it’s about being clear.
Scripts That Work (Because Sometimes You Just Need the Words)
People often freeze because they don’t want to sound harsh. The good news is you can be kind and firm at the same time. Try: “We’re going to alternate holidays so we can see both families,” or “This year we’re staying home, but we’d love to plan a visit in January when travel is easier.”
If the “only fair” line comes up, you can acknowledge the emotion without accepting the premise. “I’m really grateful for everything you’ve done. And I also need to make holiday plans that work for our household.” Calm, boring, repeatable—like the world’s nicest broken record.
What If They Get Upset?
They might. And that doesn’t automatically mean you’re doing something wrong. Disappointment is a normal emotion, and adults are allowed to feel it without you fixing it.
The goal isn’t to eliminate their reaction—it’s to avoid being controlled by it. If every boundary is treated like a crisis, you can still hold the line: “I hear you. This is what we’ve decided.” Then change the subject, or end the call politely if it turns into a loop.
Building New Traditions Without Burning Old Bridges
Sometimes the best way to lower the stakes is to broaden the definition of “holiday time.” If your parents want connection, offer options that aren’t tied to the exact date. A cozy weekend visit in early December, a “second Thanksgiving” in January, or a holiday brunch can still feel special without requiring you to be everywhere at once.
You can also create small rituals that travel well—matching pajamas optional, but not banned. A yearly cookie-baking day, a game night, a shared movie, a group video call with hot chocolate. These things count, even if they’re not happening under one specific roof at one specific hour.
The Bigger Shift: From Child to Adult
At the heart of this issue is a transition many families struggle with: the move from parent-child hierarchy to adult-adult relationship. Parents who adjust well learn to invite rather than demand. Adult kids who adjust well learn that love isn’t measured by mileage or calendar compliance.
If your parents are stuck on “only fair,” it may help to remember this: you’re not rejecting them by growing up. You’re doing the thing they spent years preparing you to do—build a life. The healthiest holiday plans make room for that life, instead of asking you to pause it every time there’s a festive centerpiece on sale.
More from Cultivated Comfort:
- 7 Vintage Home Items From the ’60s That Are Collectors’ Dream Finds
- 7 Vintage Home Goods That Became Collectors’ Gold
- 7 Fast-Food Chains That Changed for the Worse
- 7 Frozen Dinners That Were Better Back in the Day
As a mom of three busy boys, I know how chaotic life can get — but I’ve learned that it’s possible to create a beautiful, cozy home even with kids running around. That’s why I started Cultivated Comfort — to share practical tips, simple systems, and a little encouragement for parents like me who want to make their home feel warm, inviting, and effortlessly stylish. Whether it’s managing toy chaos, streamlining everyday routines, or finding little moments of calm, I’m here to help you simplify your space and create a sense of comfort.
But home is just part of the story. I’m also passionate about seeing the world and creating beautiful meals to share with the people I love. Through Cultivated Comfort, I share my journey of balancing motherhood with building a home that feels rich and peaceful — and finding joy in exploring new places and flavors along the way.
