It starts the same way every time: someone texts the group chat about Sunday dinner, the menu gets casually assigned, and everyone agrees to “bring something.” You know the drill—one person handles the main dish, another grabs drinks, someone offers dessert, and you volunteer to bring the one item nobody really wants to be responsible for, like salad or ice. Then your brother arrives with nothing but a smile and an appetite.
At first, it feels too petty to bring up. After all, it’s family, and the whole point is to relax, eat, and catch up. But after the fifth or sixth dinner where you’ve hauled a casserole across town while he strolls in empty-handed, the annoyance starts to simmer under the gravy.
The “Empty-Handed” Pattern That’s Hard to Ignore
This isn’t the occasional “I forgot the bread” situation. This is a consistent habit: no chips, no soda, no store-bought cookies, not even a bag of ice that melts halfway through the meal. And somehow, he still manages to leave with leftovers like he’s earned them.
What makes it extra frustrating is that everyone else seems to participate in the unspoken potluck economy. Even the cousin who claims to be “bad at cooking” shows up with a rotisserie chicken or a fancy cheese plate. Your brother, meanwhile, brings vibes.
When You Mention It, He Hits You With “Keeping Score”
Eventually, you say something—maybe gently, maybe after one too many loads of dishes. You don’t even have to make it dramatic. It can be as simple as, “Hey, can you grab drinks next time?”
And that’s when he pulls the classic move: “Why are you keeping score?” Suddenly, you’re not the person who’s been contributing; you’re the person who’s apparently turning dinner into a spreadsheet. It’s a clever deflection because it makes your reasonable request sound like a character flaw.
Why This Stuff Gets Under Your Skin (Even If It’s “Just Food”)
On the surface, it’s about a side dish or a $10 bottle of soda. But the real issue is what it represents: effort, reciprocity, and basic consideration. When one person repeatedly opts out of contributing, it quietly shifts the workload onto everyone else.
It can also poke at deeper family dynamics. Maybe he’s always been the “one who gets a pass,” or maybe you’ve been the reliable one who picks up slack without complaint. A few empty hands at dinner can feel like a much bigger story repeating itself.
The Fine Line Between “Scorekeeping” and “Fairness”
There is such a thing as toxic scorekeeping, and most people can sense it. That’s the kind where every favor comes with an invoice and generosity is only performed if it’s repaid in the exact same currency. Nobody wants to feel like they’re being audited over pasta salad.
But fairness isn’t the same as scorekeeping. Noticing a pattern and asking for shared responsibility is normal adult behavior. If your brother only labels it “keeping score” when you bring it up, that’s less about your tone and more about his discomfort at being called in.
What Might Be Going On With Your Brother (Without Excusing It)
Sometimes the empty-handed guest isn’t being malicious; they’re being avoidant. He may assume someone else will cover it, or he might not understand the social expectation if he’s never hosted. Or he could be stuck in a “family equals free pass” mindset where showing up is his contribution.
Money can be another factor, even if it’s not obvious. People who feel financially squeezed sometimes hide it with defensiveness, because saying “I can’t afford it right now” feels vulnerable. Still, if that’s the case, there are plenty of low-cost ways to participate—like bringing ice, helping clean up, or picking up a $3 loaf of bread.
How Families Accidentally Enable the Situation
Family gatherings are built on momentum. If dinner’s happening no matter what, and your brother knows nobody will turn him away, he doesn’t experience a consequence for opting out. The system keeps working, just slightly more unfairly each time.
And most families are conflict-avoidant by design. It’s easier to roll your eyes than to risk an argument at the table. But that “easier” choice quietly teaches him that this is fine—and teaches you that your irritation doesn’t matter.
A More Effective Way to Bring It Up (So It Doesn’t Turn Into a Debate)
If the conversation keeps getting derailed by “keeping score,” it helps to frame it as logistics instead of morality. Try something like: “We’re trying to split costs and effort more evenly. Can you be on drinks and ice for the next two dinners?” It’s specific, concrete, and hard to argue with without sounding ridiculous.
It also helps to talk about it when you’re not hungry, stressed, and holding a serving spoon like a weapon. A quick call midweek is often better than a tense aside while everyone’s within earshot. You’re not asking for a confession; you’re asking for a plan.
If He Still Won’t Contribute, Here Are Some Real-World Options
You can reduce how much you personally carry. If you’re always the one bringing the “extra” items, stop volunteering for them. Bring what you said you’d bring and let the gaps be visible—awkward, yes, but sometimes a missing stack of paper plates says more than an argument ever will.
Another option is to rotate responsibilities more formally. Families often resist structure until they realize structure prevents resentment. A simple text like “Next week: Brother brings drinks, I’ll bring dessert, Mom does main” turns it into a shared plan instead of a personal grievance.
And if you want to keep it light while still making the point, humor can help—carefully. “Hey, you’ve been on a long streak of bringing nothing but charm. Can you bring chips next time?” If he laughs and agrees, great. If he bristles, that tells you the defensiveness is doing a lot of work.
The Bigger Goal: Keeping Family Dinner Warm Without Becoming the Household Treasurer
No one wants to turn family time into a transactional event. But it’s also hard to enjoy dinner when you feel taken advantage of, even in small ways. Resentment has a sneaky way of showing up in your tone, your patience, and your willingness to host.
The healthiest version of this isn’t you silently absorbing the burden or him being publicly shamed. It’s a clear expectation that everyone contributes something—money, food, or effort—and nobody has to pretend it’s fine when it’s not. Because “we’re family” should mean people look out for each other, not that one person always gets to coast.
More from Cultivated Comfort:
- 7 Vintage Home Items From the ’60s That Are Collectors’ Dream Finds
- 7 Vintage Home Goods That Became Collectors’ Gold
- 7 Fast-Food Chains That Changed for the Worse
- 7 Frozen Dinners That Were Better Back in the Day
As a mom of three busy boys, I know how chaotic life can get — but I’ve learned that it’s possible to create a beautiful, cozy home even with kids running around. That’s why I started Cultivated Comfort — to share practical tips, simple systems, and a little encouragement for parents like me who want to make their home feel warm, inviting, and effortlessly stylish. Whether it’s managing toy chaos, streamlining everyday routines, or finding little moments of calm, I’m here to help you simplify your space and create a sense of comfort.
But home is just part of the story. I’m also passionate about seeing the world and creating beautiful meals to share with the people I love. Through Cultivated Comfort, I share my journey of balancing motherhood with building a home that feels rich and peaceful — and finding joy in exploring new places and flavors along the way.
