The price on the rental car website is rarely the price at the end of the counter. Somewhere between the booking page and the keys, the total tends to grow.

AARP’s smart guide to car rentals (2025) walks through the usual suspects, and an older AARP money-saving tips post (2013) adds a few more. Here are nine costs, fees and rules worth checking before you click Reserve. Rules differ by company and by state, so confirm each one with the company you choose.
1. The Average Rental Runs About $86 A Day Before You Add Extras
AARP’s 2025 guide cites a 2024 Consumer Reports survey that found members spent about $86 per day on rentals, including taxes and fees. That works out to roughly $600 a week.
Use that as a reality check. A rental that seems like a bargain at the start can end up near that figure by the time taxes and fees arrive. If a quote looks far lower than that, look closely at which extras are not yet counted in the headline price.
AARP’s guide also mentions member discounts of up to 30% off through Expedia and 35% through select rental companies. Ask whether a discount code applies to the exact car and dates you want.
The 2013 post suggests another habit. Book with several companies early, since cancellations are usually penalty-free, and recheck for lower rates as your trip gets closer.
2. Airport Pickup Can Cost 20% Or More Extra
According to AARP (2025), airport locations often add surcharges and facility fees. Off-airport locations may cost 20% or more less.
AARP’s 2013 post agrees that airport and municipal fees usually make the airport counter the most expensive option. Its suggestion is to take public transit or a taxi to an off-airport agency, which can be worth it on a longer rental.
3. Paying By Debit Card May Freeze Hundreds Of Dollars
Some companies place a hold of the estimated rental cost plus $200 to $500 when you pay by debit card, AARP reports (2025). That money is tied up until the car comes back.
If you plan to use a debit card, ask the company about its hold policy before you arrive. A call ahead can save you an unpleasant surprise at the counter.
4. Your Age Can Change The Rules, Especially Abroad
AARP (2025) says the minimum rental age is 18 or 21, depending on the state. It adds that there is no maximum age if you have a good driving record.
Overseas is another story. AARP notes that some countries and international companies set age caps between 70 and 80, so read the fine print before booking a trip abroad. It also says an international driving permit is often recommended and sometimes required.
5. A Second Driver Does Not Have To Cost Extra
AARP (2025) reports that Alamo, Enterprise and National add a spouse or domestic partner for free. It also says AARP and AAA members get a second driver as part of their deal.
That is worth knowing if you split the driving on a long haul. Always list every person who might take the wheel, since an unlisted driver can cause trouble if there is an accident.
6. Mileage Caps And Border Rules Can Sneak Into The Contract
AARP (2025) notes that some rentals limit mileage or restrict travel by state, and that crossing into Mexico or Canada may require extra permission. Most contracts also prohibit driving off paved roads, and mud cleaning may bring extra charges.
The 2013 AARP post adds that dropping a car outside the rental metro area usually carries an extra charge. Many companies allow a drop-off within the metro area at no extra cost, such as at a train station.
7. The Insurance Pitch At The Counter May Double Your Bill
AARP (2025) says rental counter insurance is often unnecessary if your personal auto policy or credit card already provides coverage. The 2013 post goes further, saying the rental company’s coverage can more than double the total cost.
The same post lists emergency roadside assistance and supplemental liability insurance as optional add-ons that agents may pitch. Call your insurance agent and card issuer before the trip and decide what you want before you reach the counter.
8. Refueling Charges Can Run Up To 30 Cents More Per Gallon
According to AARP (2025), companies may charge up to 30 cents more per gallon for refueling, so filling the tank yourself is usually cheaper. Keep the gas receipt as proof.
Prepaid fuel deserves caution, too. AARP’s 2013 post warns that if you return the car with more than a gallon or two left, you lose money on the deal.
9. Prepaid Toll Transponders Add Up Quickly
AARP (2025) says prepaid toll transponders add cost. Using your own transponder, if the state accepts it, may save money.
Ask the company how tolls are billed before you leave the lot. It is a small detail that can show up as a big charge on your card weeks later. Take a photo of the dashboard and fuel gauge when you pick up and drop off, too.
A little homework turns a rental from a gamble into a plain purchase. Run through these nine points and you will know what you are paying for before the keys are in your hand.
More Stories You May Like
- 5 Rules to Settle Before Adult Kids Move Back Home So Rent, Chores and Timelines Do Not Quietly Turn Into Resentment Under Your Roof
- Wedding Budget Creep Traps From Guest List Growth to While We Are at It Upgrades That Quietly Blow the Plan Before the Big Day
- 5 Ways to Set a Secret Santa Limit Before Cost Creep Makes the Office and Family Gift Swap Feel Unfair to Everyone Who Joins In

