You sit down, open the menu, and everything sounds wonderful. But the people who cook for a living sometimes order very differently than the rest of us. Plenty of chefs have shared the dishes they quietly steer around.

We pulled from two published roundups, Mashed (originally published 2017, updated September 2025) and The Takeout (July 2025). These are the chefs’ personal opinions, not rules, but six dishes came up in both.
1. Eggs Benedict Is A Brunch Gamble, Chefs Say
Mashed reports that Anthony Bourdain wrote in his book Kitchen Confidential that hollandaise can harbor bacteria, is rarely made to order, and that brunch often relies on leftover ingredients. That is his view, passed along by Mashed. If you love a good brunch, the lesson is to pick a place that clearly cooks to order.
The Takeout quotes Chef Clifton Dickerson of the Auguste Escoffier School of Culinary Arts, who calls hollandaise “temperamental, especially during a busy brunch rush.” He says it can break or sit too long.
2. The House Salad May Not Be So Fresh
Mashed cites Chef Kayson Chong, who finds the house salad boring and prefers chef-created dishes built on seasonal ingredients. In his view, it is the least interesting thing on the menu, and your money is better spent on a plate the kitchen is excited about.
The Takeout’s Chef Suhum Jang of Hortus NYC goes further. She says leftover scraps may be used and greens may not be fresh, and that heavy dressings can “mask this lack of quality.”
3. Restaurant Chicken Too Often Arrives Overcooked
Mashed quotes Chef Ryan Ososky, who says chicken “tends to be overcooked at most restaurants.” It is a safe, common choice, and that is exactly the problem, since a busy kitchen cooking dozens of orders can easily push a lean cut past its prime.
The Takeout’s Chef Justin Robinson, known from Food Network and Fox’s MasterChef, agrees that chicken is often “overcooked and under-seasoned unless handled with intention.” Chef Luke Shaffer adds that restaurant chicken breast can come out “sawdust dry,” and says menus usually offer more interesting options.
4. Fish Can Be Risky Unless You Trust The Kitchen
Mashed shares the advice of Hawaii Chef Felix Tai: skip fish on Mondays. His reasoning is that local fish markets close on Sunday, so Monday fish may be old.
The Takeout’s Chef William Eick says he avoids fish dishes unless the fish is locally sourced or the restaurant has a strong reputation. Chef Chaz Lindsay of Jackson, Mississippi, says cooking fish well is very difficult and that “more often than not, I find it underwhelming.”
5. “Processed” Food Is A Hard Pass For These Chefs
Mashed cites Chef Michael Smith, who says processed food is linked to leading causes of death and does not taste as good as fresh food. His point is that you can get processed food anywhere.
The Takeout quotes Chef Mawa McQueen of Crepe Therapy Cafe: “I never order anything processed or pre-made.” She prefers craft over convenience, so ask your server what is made in house. Fresh soup, house-baked bread and sauces made from scratch are good signs.
6. Gimmicky Specials And Trendy Plates Rarely Deliver
Mashed reports that Gordon Ramsay has said long specials lists are not truly special, and that dishes with gimmicky names often are not better. A short, confident menu is a better sign. When a server rattles off a dozen specials, it is fair to ask which one the cooks would order themselves.
The Takeout’s Chef Jorge Dionicio of Kansha in Manhattan says: “I value food that’s rooted in intention, not trend.” Chef Clifton Dickerson calls dishes made more for Instagram than for eating a “hard pass.”
What To Do With This Advice At Your Next Dinner Out
Before you cross anything off your list, remember that these are opinions from individual chefs, and plenty of restaurants cook every one of these dishes beautifully. The common thread is trust: a kitchen you know and a menu that sticks to what it does well. A neighborhood spot that cooks the same dozen dishes all week often beats a place with an encyclopedia for a menu.
Ask what is fresh today, and ask what the kitchen is proudest of. If you love a dish, order it. If a place has a huge menu and a long list of specials, you may want to pick the thing that sounds simplest and most seasonal.
Chefs also have a gentle reminder about substitutions. Mashed cites Chef Christopher Faulkner, who says that unless you have an allergy, the chef has already balanced the dish. Allergies always come first, of course, and a good kitchen will welcome the conversation. Everything else is a matter of taste, and a dish prepared the way the chef intended is usually the dish at its best.
A little curiosity at the table goes a long way. Next time, you might skip the safe choice and try the dish the server lights up about. That is often where the cooks put their pride, and it is how many of us discover a new favorite. Share this list with the friend who always orders the same thing, and see what happens.
More Stories You May Like
- Cruise Ship Crew Say Passengers Who Hang Up Wet Towels And Stack Their Own Dishes Think They Are Helping But Can Actually Get The Staff In Trouble
- Leftover Restaurant Takeout Is Safe Only for So Long and the Doggy Bag Rules Say Refrigerate Within Two Hours and Toss After 3 to 4 Days
- Cruiser Who Just Got Off Royal Caribbean’s Utopia Of The Seas Says She Has Outgrown Three Night Cruises And Warns Big Ships Need At Least Four Nights

