A bowl of creamy mashed potatoes topped with chives.

Every Thanksgiving table has the same fight going on quietly in the middle of it. Mashed potatoes and stuffing both want the last spoonful of gravy, and nobody wants to pick a side.

A bowl of creamy mashed potatoes topped with chives.

Home cook @cocolarkincooks has an answer that ends the argument: put them in the same dish. She calls it a mash-up of mashed potatoes and stuffing, and she says it is “absolutely next level goodness.”

View this post on Instagram

She opens by calling it “the best Thanksgiving side that you’ve never heard of.” Then she makes it, step by step, and it is easier than it sounds.

It Starts With Stale Bread Soaking Up Turkey Stock

The base is plain old stale bread. She covers it with turkey stock and lets it soak until the bread has taken in all the liquid, then gives it a light mash and sets it aside to rest.

That is the whole secret of a good stuffing, and it is a smart way to use bread that has gone a little hard on the counter. Dry bread drinks up flavor the way fresh bread cannot, so nothing turns to paste.

The Potatoes Stay Chunky On Purpose

While the bread sits, she boils potatoes and mashes them by hand. She says she does not want a super smooth mash, and she stirs in a little butter and a little cream.

Her words on the result: “These are a heavier mash. They’re not gonna be super light.” That is exactly what you want here, because a loose, fluffy mash would disappear into the bread. A sturdy, rustic mash holds its shape and gives each bite some body.

Once the potatoes are done, she mixes the bread with her hands and sets it aside again. Using your hands is a nice touch. You can feel when it is evenly moist without squashing it.

Ham Hock, Parsnip And Leek Give It A Savory Backbone

Next comes the vegetable mix. She cooks celery, onion, parsnip and a little leek, then adds a ham hock and fresh herbs, salt and pepper. She covers the pan and lets it cook for about 10 minutes.

After that, she pours in some white wine and cooks it on high until the wine has reduced. Reducing matters because it burns off the sharp edge and leaves the sweetness behind.

The parsnip is the quiet star. It brings a gentle, nutty sweetness that sits well beside salty ham and rich potatoes, and plenty of home cooks never think to use it outside of a roasting pan.

“You Don’t Want It To Be Too Compacted” Before The Cheese Goes On

Now everything comes together. She adds the vegetable mixture to the potatoes and the bread and gives it what she calls a loose mix. Her warning is simple: “You don’t want it to be too compacted.”

Then she stirs in Gruyere cheese. She butters a casserole dish or baking pan, spreads the mixture in, paints the top with a little olive oil or butter, and sprinkles a little more cheese over the top.

Keeping the mix loose leaves little air pockets, which is how you get a side dish that is creamy in the middle and crisp at the edges instead of a dense brick.

Twenty-Five Minutes Covered, Twenty More To Crisp The Top

Into the oven it goes, covered, for 25 minutes. Then she takes the cover off and bakes it another 20 minutes so the cheese on top can brown.

When she pulls it out, she says it is bubbling and “smells incredible.” She lets it sit for a minute before digging in, and that short rest helps it settle so it scoops cleanly instead of sliding apart.

The first spoonful reaction is the best part of her video. She says the cheesy top is “absolute heaven” and admits she had never thought of this combination before. Her verdict is that it is “going to become a Thanksgiving freaking classic.”

How To Make It Work At Your Own Table

If you want to try it, here is what the method teaches, and a few ways to make Thanksgiving Day easier.

  • Start the bread early. Stale bread is the point, so tear it up a day or two ahead and leave it out on a tray.
  • Keep the mash chunky. Mash by hand with a fork or masher, not a mixer, which can turn potatoes gluey.
  • Make the vegetable mix ahead. Cooking the celery, onion, parsnip, leek and herbs earlier in the day means you only have to combine and bake.
  • Do not pack the dish. Spread it loosely so the heat can reach the middle and the top can crisp.
  • Give it a rest. A minute or two out of the oven makes it easier to serve.

Stuffing and mashed potatoes are two of the most loved dishes at any holiday meal, and this one gives you both in a single pan. It also saves oven space and a burner, which any host knows is worth its weight in gold on the fourth Thursday of November.

If you have a ham bone or leftover turkey stock in the fridge, this is a fine way to use them. And if you have a houseful of guests who cannot agree on what to pile on their plates, a casserole like this may be the peace treaty your table needs.

Credit for the idea goes to @cocolarkincooks, who shared the recipe on Instagram.

More Stories You May Like

+ posts

Similar Posts