It started with a TikTok. A couple behind the Florida food channel @thealtemlife saw a retro burger spot in downtown Orlando making the rounds, and they headed over to see if it deserved the buzz.

The place is J. Lucy’s Burgers, serving grass-fed burgers, tallow fries and milkshakes. Both of them say they have had grass-fed burgers before and count them among the best they have eaten.
They were hungry, the air smelled delicious, and the only real worry was where to put the car.
J. Lucy’s sits off Mills Avenue in the Mills 50 area, close to the Science Center. The couple says it opened in August and is labeled a pop-up online, though it looks like a long-term pop-up with no closing date listed.
“Parking’s Extremely Tough,” So They Got Lucky And Grabbed A Street Spot
The couple says parking is the hardest part of the visit. There is almost no lot, so they ended up on the street and felt lucky to find a space.
They arrived around 6:15 on a Saturday, and the street behind them was very busy. Their tip is to come as soon as you can, since nobody knows how long a pop-up will stay.
The hours are Sunday through Thursday from 11:30 a.m. to 10 p.m. and Friday and Saturday from 11:30 a.m. to 2 a.m.
A Retro Counter, A PB&J Milkshake, And An Order Number They Can Not Forget
The retro look won them over. They loved the old-school chairs and a retro soda machine out front, and the creator said she wanted one of her own. The restrooms are outside, and they believe you have to ask for a key.
You order at the counter from a menu of cheeseburgers, bacon burgers, veggie burgers, chicken nuggets, fries and shakes. Extras include lettuce, tomato and a gluten-free bun.
One of them ordered a bacon burger with house sauce and a PB&J milkshake, “just for the heck of it.” The other got a single cheeseburger with no pickles or onions and a cookies and cream shake.
With burgers, fries and shakes, the total was around $50. They were order number 96, picked up their food at the side of the counter, and ate outside under cover, where the music was quieter.
The PB&J Shake Tasted “Exactly Like” The Sandwich, With Real Jam Inside
The shake went first. She says it tastes just like a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, with a peanut butter flavor and real jam when you drink it.
The fries came next, good and crispy, with “spot on” seasoning. They compared them to Freddy’s and Steak ‘n Shake. The burger got a “top quality ingredients on a very simple meal” rating.
The bun was perfect, the bacon and cheese worked, and the burger was flavorful from the first bite to the last. One of them admitted to being sad over the final bite and said he should have ordered a double.
Where It Lands Against Five Guys And A Mount Dora Burger Legend
The couple has a ranking system. Their number one burger, they say, is the Wagyu burger at Butcher’s Nook in Mount Dora, which they call the best burger anywhere.
J. Lucy’s did not top it, but they put it in their top three, tied with Five Guys. Five Guys, they say, is expensive but “one of the most consistent” burgers you can eat. The burger at Sanaa at Disney’s Animal Kingdom Lodge also makes their top five.
The only criticism was that the house sauce was light on the burger. One of them is a saucy person and would load it on. The staff gave a side cup of it at no charge when asked, even though the menu lists no price.
The Mystery House Sauce Has A Tang That Sounds Like Yogurt
The two debated what is in it. They guessed a mayo-based aioli, then something with Dijon, because of the tang. One of them thought it tasted like yogurt.
Either way, they liked it with the fries. It is tangy without being overpowering.
The staff were friendly throughout, and they say you can hear your name called outside, which makes waiting easy. Trays go on a rack inside when you finish.
A Record Shop Couple And A Request For Seed Oil Free Spots
While they ate, a couple who watch their channel stopped to say hello. They own Remix Record Shop nearby, come to J. Lucy’s often for burgers, and mentioned a Thai place they like. The creators plan to visit the record shop.
The creators also asked viewers for more Orlando suggestions, including seed oil free options. They say they do not call themselves foodies. They just like good food and enjoy showing it.
How To Order At J. Lucy’s For The Full Experience
Their advice if you go:
- Order a regular or bacon burger, fries and a shake, since the fries are plentiful and the shake is filling.
- Ask for house sauce on the side if you like extra flavor.
- Look for street parking early and sit outside on a nice evening.
- Order, pick up, and take it home if the crowd is thick.
Their final verdict: the burger met their expectations “and more,” the fries were fantastic, and either shake is worth it. They said they would recommend it and thanked the TikTok users who shared the spot.
More Stories You May Like
- Brightline Parent Company Files for Chapter 11 With $4.4 Billion in Debt but Says the Miami to Orlando Trains Will Keep Running as Usual
- Five Guys Receipt Showed $24.10 For A Burger Fries And Soda As Restaurant Chains Pushed Prices Too Far And Lost Their Customers
- Harvard Study That Followed Lives for Nearly 80 Years Found Happy Relationships at 50 Predicted Health at 80 Better Than Cholesterol Did

