Is cruising still worth the money? A traveler who has been sailing for almost 20 years and has taken around 50 cruises says her answer has changed, though not the way you might expect. Creator @CruisingKat says two recent land trips overseas, one through Italy and Spain and one through England, Scotland and Ireland, changed how she looks at travel.

She is not blind to what has happened to the cruise business. Fares have gone up, things that used to be included now cost extra, service is not what it used to be, and there are more packages, upgrades and reservations that all invite you to spend.
“I Don’t Consider Everything That Costs Extra Nickel And Diming”
Many longtime cruisers lump every added charge into one big bucket called nickel and diming, and she does not agree with all of it. She likes having choices, whether that is a specialty restaurant, a spa treatment, a beach club or a better internet package, because she does not have to buy any of them.
Her test is simple. If you normally skip the drink package, Wi-Fi and specialty dining, the cruise line is not nickel and diming you just because those things exist. If you need all of them to have the vacation you want, then they belong in the price you compare, and for other people the lower fare without extras is the better deal.
She also says the frustration is not really about money. People miss how cruising used to feel, with the personal service, the little touches, the more special food and the less crowded ships. Nobody is upset about losing a chocolate on the pillow, she says. They miss what that chocolate stood for.
A Longtime Cruiser Who Says “I Am Paying More And Getting Less” Is Right, But That Is Only Half The Math
When someone who has cruised for 20 or 30 years says they are paying more and getting less, she says they are right. But she argues that comparing today’s cruise with one from 15 years ago only shows what changed, not where your money is best spent today.
“I cannot book a cruise from 2010 today,” she says. The honest comparison is between the cruise you can book now and the other vacations you can book now, and she warns that people often imagine a land vacation where hotel prices never rose and no resort fee exists. Sometimes, she says, you get to the greener grass and discover it has a parking fee.
She also notes that the comparison has to be fair in both directions. Driving to Florida, staying in a budget motel and eating fast food may cost less than a cruise, but that is not the same trip. Comparing a cheap inside cabin to a five-star Paris hotel is just as unfair.
Land Trip One: Five Days In Italy And Spain Cost More Than Seven Nights At Sea
Her best test came on a Mediterranean trip last month. She and her family took a seven-night cruise and spent five days on land in Italy and Spain before and after it, staying in four different hotels.
Those five land days cost considerably more than the seven-night cruise, she says. Every night needed a hotel, every day needed meals and transportation, and each activity was its own expense. She also changed hotels four times in five days, while on the ship she visited six ports and her luggage stayed in the closet.
Food was not a clear win for land either. One dinner in Europe cost about 100 euros for two, around $130, and the food was bland. Unlike in a cruise ship dining room, where she can ask for something else, the bill was already paid. Her point is that real restaurants and hotels can disappoint just like ships do.
Land Trip Two: Planning England, Scotland And Ireland Felt Like “A Second Job”
Her other land trip took in England, Scotland and Ireland over 10 days. Her son had graduated from university and wanted to spend St. Patrick’s Day in Dublin, and the family loved it.
But it was the hardest vacation she has ever planned. She says she spent close to six months working out where to stay, how trains, subways and local transport worked in each place, and what to do with luggage between checkout and the next hotel. At some point, she says, “I felt like I had a second job just planning transportation in Europe.”
On the Mediterranean cruise, she handled most ports herself and booked only two paid excursions. She took a train to Monaco on her own, and with the hotel, dinner and luggage already solved, she could spend the day enjoying the place.
An 11-Night Asia Sailing Shows Where Cruising Still Wins
Her biggest argument for cruising is time. Most people do not have unlimited vacation days, and a ship lets you sample many places quickly so you can find the ones you love. She is looking at an 11-night Asia sailing from Tokyo to Singapore with stops in countries like Taiwan and South Korea.
It worked that way last time. She and her family loved Rome and Venice and are already talking about going back, while Barcelona was enjoyable but did not leave her wishing for a full week there. That, she says, is valuable information.
She also says “worth it” and “cheap” are not the same thing. The most valuable vacation is not always the one with the lowest bottom-line price.
When A Cruise Is The Wrong Tool
She is clear that cruising has limits. If you want several days in one place, a ship may be wrong, since ports can change, weather can alter an itinerary and you do not control how long the ship stays.
A bad experience often comes from the wrong pick, not from cruising itself. Someone who hates crowds and books the biggest, busiest ship may swear off cruises, and so may someone who wants nonstop activities and picks a tiny quiet ship because the fare was low.
Her Answer Changed: Start With Where You Want To Go, Not Which Cruise
After both land trips, her final answer is still yes, cruising is worth it, but the way she gets there has changed. Not because it is as cheap as it used to be, she says, and not because every cruise is a good deal. But when she prices what it would cost to rebuild the same vacation on land, with hotel, meals, transportation and entertainment, she still sees tremendous value. Her advice now is to start with where you want to go, what you want to experience and how much time you have, and only then compare what a cruise and a land trip would cost.
More Stories You May Like
- 7 Things to Get in Writing Before Booking an All Inclusive Resort Because Not Everything You Expect Is Always Actually Included in the Price
- Cruiser Who Just Got Off Royal Caribbean’s Utopia Of The Seas Says She Has Outgrown Three Night Cruises And Warns Big Ships Need At Least Four Nights
- Nine Affordable European Cities Where Travelers Over 60 Can Stay A Month With Rent Around €720 And One Even Has Free Public Transit

