Dimly lit restaurant interior with tables and chairs

A new Jamaican restaurant in Winnipeg has not even opened its doors yet, and it is already the talk of the city. Miss Christine’s Kitchen announced that its new dining room, set to open November 30, will welcome only guests ages 15 and older.

Dimly lit restaurant interior with tables and chairs

Owner and chef Christine Pattison says she is not budging. “I’m not backing down,” she said. “I’m sticking to my guns.”

“An Intimate Setting For Adults To Get Away” Is How The Post Explains The Rule

The announcement went up on the restaurant’s Facebook page in early November. It said the restaurant strives “to create a warm, cozy and relaxing atmosphere where our guests can enjoy great food, good company and memorable dining experiences.”

The post described a “comfortable, intimate setting for adults to get away, unwind and enjoy quality time, whether it’s a romantic evening, a special meeting or simply a chance to relax and recharge.” It then added the rule: “To maintain the intimate setting of our restaurant, our dining room welcomes guests ages 15 and older.”

It closed by asking guests to respect the dining policy so every guest gets “a true Miss Christine’s Dining Experience.”

No Kids’ Menu, No High Chairs And “Nothing In Here For A Child”

The restaurant sits on Ellice Avenue in Winnipeg’s West End, and guests are seated by reservation. There will be no kids’ menu, no high chairs and no changing table.

Pattison describes the room as dark, tiny and seating about 30 people, with “nothing in here for a child.” Her promotions feature braised oxtail, jerk chicken and fried plantains.

She is 55, a mother and a grandmother of seven, with grandchildren aged four to 21. She says the policy comes from years of running a restaurant inside the Chalet Hotel, where she says children were a steady disturbance to other diners and customers often asked for later reservations or out-of-the-way tables to avoid them.

“Why Is It Fair For My Customers To Work Hard For Their Money?”

Pattison has given plenty of interviews, and her case is blunt. “Why is it fair for my customers to work hard for their money, come to have a nice experience and then have kids running around?” she asked, telling a Winnipeg newspaper that adults “deserve a break.”

To a television interviewer she said, “It’s not like [kids] can’t eat my food. You have the option of picking up… so I don’t see where the [claims of] discrimination are coming in.” She added, “Why are you bringing a child to a darkly lit restaurant that seats 30 people with nothing to entertain children? You’re ruining that child’s experience.”

On a radio show she said, “If anyone says that their kids never drive them crazy, they are a big fat liar.” She described a visit from two grandchildren, aged four and six, who left taps running in the washroom, played with burning candles and dragged things around.

Parents And Child-Free Diners Split Right Down The Middle

Replies on the post ran both ways. One father wrote, “As a father of three kids under 8 years old, I fully support this. Not everywhere needs to accommodate kids.” Another reader said, “As someone who is child-free, there should actually be more restaurants that implement this.”

A third added, “I’ll gladly leave my kids home to eat in an adult-only restaurant.” Pattison says many people also emailed her messages of support.

Critics were just as firm. One told a TV crew, “If it’s a restaurant, there should be no age limit. It’s not like it’s a bar where you’re serving drinks. I think parents should have the right to take their children to a restaurant.” Another said, “We live in a world right now that is excluding enough people.”

A Nearby Mom Of Four Says She May File A Human Rights Complaint

Crystal Dale, 44, lives nearby with her partner and four children aged three to 10. She said, “You can’t… discriminate against my family and turn us around at the door because I have children,” and said she may file a complaint with the Manitoba Human Rights Commission.

Some critics posted one-star reviews and made false claims about food poisoning and server misconduct, even though the restaurant has no servers or dine-in service yet. Another called Pattison a “drama farmer.”

Pattison posted some of those reviews on her page and asked for their removal. One report says she scrubbed the original negative comments from her page, while another says the negative comments “appear to have been removed.”

What Manitoba Law Says About Age And Family Status

Joelle Pastora Sala, a lawyer at the Public Interest Law Centre in Winnipeg, said businesses must follow Manitoba’s human rights code, which covers age and family status. She said whether a case for discrimination exists depends on the circumstances and the harm a complainant experiences, and stressed she was speaking generally.

Pattison says she called the commission and later posted that it told her a complaint requires proof of discrimination and harm. She quoted the answer as, “They said it’s all good.”

Adults-Only Dining Is Having A Moment

Winnipeg is not alone in this debate. A recent adults-only JetBlue charter flight with Virgin Voyages, from JFK to Fort Lauderdale, was billed as “Do Not Disturb” for passengers 18 and over.

If you plan to dine at a restaurant with a posted age policy, check the rules when you book. Reservations are the easiest place to find out who the room is built for, and a quick call saves a doorway argument later.

More Stories You May Like

+ posts

Similar Posts