Buying a refrigerator is one of the biggest appliance decisions in a home, and the numbers behind reliability can be sobering. A large survey found that nearly half of owners had a problem.

Consumer Reports members reported on over 85,000 refrigerators purchased since 2016. Nearly half of respondents experienced a problem such as a broken ice maker or compressor.
The findings were summarized October 26 by Jaimie Mackey in a Tasting Table article.
LG Tops The Reliability Chart
LG, a South Korean appliance company, earned the top spot for predicted reliability among top-freezer refrigerators. LG’s top-freezer models received the highest predicted reliability score from customers.
LG also ranked relatively well on owner satisfaction compared with other brands.
Samsung had the second-highest predicted reliability score, based on member survey data.
Strong Marks In Testing
All LG top-freezers recommended by Consumer Reports received high marks for thermostat performance, temperature uniformity and energy efficiency.
Those three traits matter in daily life. A thermostat that holds steady keeps food safe, and an efficient fridge helps keep your electric bill down.
The Top Pick In Each Size
The best choice depends on how much space you have. The article lists top-ranked models by width.
- 28 inches and narrower: Samsung holds the top two spots, with an LG model in third.
- 29 to 30 inches: the LG LTCS20030S, a 30-inch model, is the top-ranked top-freezer.
- Over 31 inches: the LG LRTLS2403S, a 33-inch model, is the highest-ranked pick.
Why Top Freezers Still Appeal
Top-freezer refrigerators are a classic design, with the freezer above the fresh food compartment. They are often simpler than models with ice dispensers and French doors, and fewer features can mean fewer parts that can break.
They are also usually more affordable. For many households, a plain, sturdy fridge is exactly what they need.
Measure Before You Shop
Appliances must fit your space. Measure the width, height and depth of the opening, and leave a little room around the sides and back for airflow.
Check the path from the front door to the kitchen, too. A fridge that fits the opening but not the doorway is a costly mistake.
Ask the store about delivery, installation and removal of your old unit. Some stores include these services, while others charge extra.
Protect Your Investment
A few habits can help any refrigerator last longer.
- Keep the refrigerator at 40 degrees Fahrenheit or below and the freezer at 0 degrees, and use an appliance thermometer to check.
- Clean the coils, usually at the back or bottom, a couple of times a year so the compressor does not work harder than it should.
- Wipe the door gaskets and check that they seal tightly, since a loose seal wastes energy.
- Avoid overpacking, which blocks airflow and leads to warm spots.
Read The Warranty And Think About Repairs
Before you buy, learn what the warranty covers and for how long. A longer warranty can be worth a few extra dollars if parts such as the compressor are included.
Find out how repairs work in your area. Look for authorized service technicians nearby, since a repair delay can mean spoiled food.
Keep your receipt, model number and serial number in a folder. If something goes wrong, you will have what you need to file a claim quickly.
What To Do When A Fridge Breaks
If your refrigerator fails, keep the doors closed as much as possible. A closed refrigerator keeps food safe for about four hours during a power outage, and a full freezer holds its temperature for roughly 48 hours.
Move perishables to a cooler with ice if repairs will take a while. When in doubt, throw it out, since food safety matters more than saving a few dollars of groceries.
Is A Simple Fridge The Smart Choice
With nearly half of owners reporting problems, simplicity looks smarter. Features like ice makers and water dispensers add parts that can fail, and those are the problems the survey described.
If you rarely use an ice maker, consider a model without one, or use trays. You may save money and avoid one of the most common repair calls.
Think about which features you really use. A well-built top-freezer with good temperature control and energy efficiency can serve a family for years.
Buying Tips For Bargain Hunters
Appliance sales often peak around holiday weekends, so watch for markdowns. Floor models and open-box items can offer savings too, but check the warranty carefully.
Compare the yearly energy cost on the yellow label. A model that costs a bit more to buy may save money over its lifetime.
Ask about rebates from your local utility company. Many offer cash back for efficient models.
Take Care Of What You Have
If your current fridge is running well, a few minutes of maintenance can keep it going. Pull it out to vacuum the coils, empty the drip pan if there is one and replace the water filter on schedule.
A little attention now can postpone a big purchase, and that is good news for any household budget.
More Stories You May Like
- 7 Road Trip Mistakes That Can Strand You Like Skipped Tire Checks, Low Fuel and No Backup Plan When the Phone Signal Disappears
- Packed Drive Thru Lines Had Cars Backed Up At An In N Out Off Sunset Boulevard And The Wait Inside Alone Took About 10 Minutes
- Cruise Drink Packages Specialty Dining And Daily Gratuities Add Up Fast So Budget For Them Before You Ever Board The Ship

