Bringing your own bottle to a restaurant sounds like a smart way to save money. You have a special wine tucked away, a nice dinner planned, and a table waiting.

But the restaurant has a say in how it works. In a Wine Spectator feature from October 2019 titled Sommelier Roundtable: BYO Dos and Don’ts, five wine professionals from across the country explained what guests get wrong.
Here are five things you should never expect when you bring your own bottle to a restaurant, in the words of the pros who handle those bottles every night. Fees vary from place to place, so call ahead to learn your restaurant’s policy.
The roundtable dates to 2019, but the lessons are the kind that never go out of style. Think of them as a short guide to being a welcome guest.
1. Never Expect The Corkage Fee To Be Small Or Waived
A corkage fee is what a restaurant charges to open and serve your wine. The roundtable gave real numbers.
Amy Mundwiler of Maple & Ash in Chicago said her restaurant charges a $50 corkage fee per bottle. Carrie Lyn Strong of Casa Lever in New York said hers is $55 per bottle, and Elizabeth Kelso of Craft in Los Angeles said $30 per bottle.
Mundwiler added that the fee is not listed on the wine list. That is one more reason to ask before you arrive, instead of finding out when the bill comes.
Think of the fee as paying for service. Someone has to open, pour and care for your wine, and wash and polish the glasses afterward.
2. Never Expect To Bring A Whole Case
Limits are common, and they differ from table to table. Mundwiler said guests at Maple & Ash can only bring one bottle for every two people.
Kelso said Craft allows two bottles per party, and Strong said Casa Lever allows up to two 750ml bottles. Mundwiler warned guests not to bring in multiple bottles or try to skirt the policy.
A handy rule of thumb is to pick the one bottle you truly want to share. Save the rest of the collection for a dinner at home.
3. Never Expect Decanting Or Fancy Glassware
The restaurant is not your private cellar. Mundwiler said guests should not expect decanting, special glassware and the like when they bring their own bottle.
If you care about a particular glass, ask at the time you book. Do not assume the staff will fetch crystal for a bottle you carried in.
A fancy dinner is the perfect time to treat the staff with courtesy. Kindness is the best way to get a little extra attention.
4. Never Expect To Skip The Wine List
Several of the pros made the same point. Strong said guests should always order another bottle of wine, or even a first glass of wine or Champagne, from the list.
Andrey Tolmachyov of Maude and Gwen Butcher Shop & Restaurant in Los Angeles said it is always a nice gesture to buy one bottle from the restaurant when you bring your own. Chloe Helfand of Water Grill at Caesars Palace in Las Vegas said guests should support the wine program in some way.
You do not have to order the priciest wine. A glass of bubbles to start or a bottle from the list for the main course shows you appreciate the house.
5. Never Expect The Restaurant To Shrug Off Its Loss
When you pour your own wine, the restaurant gives up income. Strong put it plainly: “a guest should understand that there is a loss of sales and/or tips.”
A little gratitude goes a long way. Strong suggested thanking the sommelier for caring for your wine and offering them a taste. Tolmachyov said to let the guests savor the bottle with their companions first, then share a taste with the sommelier, especially when he is working.
It is a small gesture that costs one sip, and it builds goodwill with the very person who may help you next time.
Kelso offered a gentle challenge for people who always bring their own. She urged guests to “take a chance on one of my suggestions next time instead of relying on their comfort zone,” pointing to list bottles priced at $40 to $50.
That advice cuts both ways. A restaurant that selects wines with care wants its guests to taste them.
Mundwiler had a final tip for anyone hoping for an exception. Respect the policy, and if you want a favor, ask nicely and smile.
Remember that these are the views of five professionals at five restaurants, and each house sets its own rules. Treat their numbers as examples of what is out there, not as a standard price.
Also keep in mind that a gift of a taste to the staff, a kind word and a fair tip on the full value of the evening all help. Good manners make the corkage fee feel like a fair trade.
Call ahead, confirm the fee and the bottle limit, and plan to buy something from the list. That way everyone at the table, including the staff, goes home happy.
More Stories You May Like
- Airlines May Soon Owe You Fewer Meals and Hotels When Certain Maintenance Problems Delay Your Flight and the Rule Now Starts January 1 2027
- 5 Restaurant Menu Items Marked Market Price That Can Wreck Your Budget and the One Simple Question to Ask Your Server Before You Order
- Restaurant Wine Lists Can Nudge You Toward The Second Cheapest Bottle And Here Is How To Order Smarter Instead

