America’s Most Talked-About Cheeseburgers, Ranked Across the Country

You’re about to explore the cheeseburgers that people talk about most across the country, from cult fast-food staples to regional treasures. This guide helps you find the cheeseburgers worth seeking out, so you can pick the next place to satisfy your burger craving.

Follow along as the article breaks down why certain burgers — whether it’s a famous double-double, a classic shackburger, or a signature sourdough stack — keep conversations alive and lines long. You’ll get quick, practical reasons each burger earns attention and where it fits into America’s cheeseburger scene.

In-N-Out Double-Double Animal Style

You get two thin, smashed patties with melty American cheese and a tangy, mayo-based “secret” sauce that lifts every bite.
The patties sear to crispy edges, and mustard-grilled onions add a sweet-savory hit.

You’ll find pickles, lettuce, and tomato for crunch and balance.
If you want to try making it at home, many copycat recipes recreate that signature texture and sauce, like this copycat Double-Double Animal Style recipe.

Shake Shack ShackBurger

You’ll recognize the ShackBurger by its pillowy potato roll and soft, juicy patty.
A simple stack of lettuce, tomato, American cheese, and ShackSauce keeps flavors bright without flashy tricks.

Expect higher prices than typical fast food, but many reviewers still call it a top fast-casual cheeseburger.
If you want more detail on how it ranks among other menu items, check this ranking of Shake Shack burgers.

Five Guys Bacon Cheeseburger

You get a juicy, customizable patty paired with crispy, thick-cut bacon that stands out. Pick your cheese and a stack of toppings to make it exactly how you want.

The bacon adds noticeable texture without overpowering the beef. Fans praise Five Guys for fresh patties and straightforward flavors you can tweak at the counter.

Learn more about Five Guys’ Bacon Cheeseburger and ordering options at Five Guys’ menu page: https://fiveguysmenus.com/bacon-cheeseburger/

Culver’s ButterBurger Cheese

If you want a straightforward, no-frills cheeseburger, Culver’s ButterBurger Cheese delivers. You get a fresh, seared beef patty topped with locally made American cheese on a lightly buttered bun.

The build stays simple so the beef and cheese shine. Fans praise the juicy texture and familiar, comforting flavor that lands consistently across locations.

Order it classic or double up for extra heft. Check Culver’s menu for variations and local offerings: https://www.culvers.com/menu/butterburgers

Whataburger Double Meat with Cheese

You get two sizable patties that stay juicy and a slice of melty cheese on each—simple and satisfying. The bun holds up without getting soggy, so your burger feels sturdy in your hands.

Customize it with grilled jalapeños, bacon, or extra cheese for more kick. Reviewers often praise its hearty flavor and regional popularity, and you can read a menu ranking that mentions the Double Meat at Eat This, Not That! (link: https://www.eatthis.com/whataburger-burgers-ranked/).

Smashburger Classic Smash

You’ll notice the Classic Smash leans into a crisp crust from a hard press on a hot flat top. The patty stays thin so you get more browned surface per bite and a straightforward beef flavor.

Toppings stay simple and customizable, letting the sear carry the sandwich. Try it with melty American and their smashed-to-order texture for a quick, familiar cheeseburger fix.

Learn more about the chain’s signature method at Smashburger’s menu page (https://smashburger.com/menu/smashburgers/classic-smash).

Wendy’s Dave’s Single

You’ll find Dave’s Single built simply: a quarter-pound fresh beef patty, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, onion, ketchup, and mayo on a toasted bun.

The burger leans on clean, familiar flavors that make it easy to order when you want something classic and predictable.

If you want details on ingredients, price, or recent rankings, check this write-up of Every Single Wendy’s Burger, Tasted & Ranked for 2024.

Sonic Classic Cheeseburger

You get a straightforward cheeseburger: soft bun, thin beef patty, and a slice of American cheese.
It won’t wow you with frills, but it hits the basic fast-food cheeseburger cravings reliably.

Fans praise its nostalgic simplicity and value.
If you want comparisons and tasting notes from critics, see this ranking of Sonic’s burgers.

Jack in the Box Sourdough Jack

You’ll find a toasted sourdough sandwich stacked with a seasoned beef patty, Swiss-style cheese, bacon, tomato, mayo, and ketchup.
The tangy bread changes the texture and lifts flavors you already like from a classic burger.

Availability varies by location, so your local Jack in the Box might rotate it or offer limited variations like the Smashed Jack.
Check the chain’s menu details for current options, prices, and calories before you go: Sourdough Jack menu info.

Cheeseburger from Fuddruckers

You build this burger your way at a counter stacked with toppings, so it feels personal every time.

Patties come in generous sizes—from a third-pound up to a full pound—so pick what fits your appetite.

The fresh-baked buns and steakhouse-style toppings bar give you control over texture and flavor, and many fans praise the straightforward, hearty taste.

Find more about the chain and its menu at the official Fuddruckers site (https://www.fuddruckers.com/).

 

More from Cultivated Comfort:

• 7 Vintage Home Items From the ’60s That Are Collectors’ Dream Finds
• 7 Vintage Home Goods That Became Collectors’ Gold
• 7 Fast-Food Chains That Changed for the Worse
• 7 Frozen Dinners That Were Better Back in the Day