Margaretville, New York, has a population of 514. It has one tiny Main Street surrounded by Catskill wilderness, and a travel creator says it might be the Catskills’ best kept secret.

Travel vlogger @gabsmall says she had never heard of the quirky little town until recently. Then she started looking at real estate prices and learned it sits right on top of New York City’s water supply, and she knew she had to go.
Before she even reached town, a detour on the two-hour drive delivered a surprise she had not expected.
The World’s Largest Kaleidoscope Is Hiding In An Old Farm Silo
Along the Catskill Mountains Scenic Byway, she stops at the Emerson. A sign promises that if you think it looks like a farm silo, think again, because it is actually the world’s largest kaleidoscope.
She calls it a very random thing to find hidden in the mountains. The mirrors run almost 38 feet up, and a show called Stardust projects images filmed just for it, set to music.
She ended up with the whole room to herself and lay down on the floor. The show takes viewers on a trip across the universe to learn where the elements that make everything come from. “This is so cool,” she says. She adds that the silo holds over 5,000 pounds of glass.
A Danish Worth The Detour In Kingston
Earlier she stopped in Kingston, which is her halfway point, at Pinkerton’s Bakery. The bakery is in a cool Art Deco building that used to be a gas station.
She ordered an apple and almond Danish that looked almost too beautiful to eat. She calls it a “legendary Danish,” a little messy but worth a stop.
The drive also took her past the Phoenicia Diner, which is famous for its pancakes, and a Catskill Rail Explorers tour. She wishes she had booked that one earlier, because by the time she checked, it was full.
“Records Never Went Anywhere, Man,” Says The Town’s Only Record Store Owner
Downtown Margaretville is cute, walkable and surprisingly lively for such a small place. On Main Street she meets Heavy, who runs the coolest and only record store in town.
“I have a compulsion to buy records anyway,” he says. “Everybody’s like, ‘Records are coming back, right?’ Like, no, they never went anywhere, man.” He is also a videographer and a musician.
He tells her tourism has changed things for locals. By his analysis, 40% of the homes in the area are occupied by some sort of Airbnb or commercial entity, which means no homes for people who actually live there. With empty houses, he says, there are no locals to shop, and nobody to hire for the store.
A Cottage For $250,000 And A Main Street Building For $385,000
Margaretville is in Delaware County, one of the more affordable counties in the Catskills. It is an economic center for the county, with restaurants open every day and a hospital, which she notes is not a given in the area.
She looks at two listings. A three-story building right on Main Street with two commercial storefronts is listed at $385,000, and she points out you could live upstairs or rent it out. Then she tours a three-bedroom, one-bath bungalow, five minutes from downtown, listed at $250,000.
A local agent tells her that prices were super affordable when he arrived, then climbed after COVID and found their new level in 18 to 24 months. Now, he says, you can get turnkey and move-in from maybe $300,000.
Hiking, Honey And A Watershed Where “The Water Is Clean”
Hiking is the main event. She tackles the Balsam Fire Tower Trail, about 6 miles round trip with a little over 1,000 feet of elevation gain, and says every season is hiking season. The summit has no view until you climb the fire tower, and she says the view is totally worth it, even with the wind blowing hard.
Locals also told her she had to do the Palmer Hill Trail. It is a pretty small hill, she says, but it has some of the best views she has seen on any hike.
She also meets Kelly Adkins, who owns Honeybee Herbs, a farm and apothecary. Kelly has kept bees for 16 years and makes skin care products using honey, royal jelly, beeswax, pollen and propolis, plus tinctures, elderberry syrup and fire cider.
Because the town is in the watershed, Kelly says, an organization makes sure the water stays clean and there is no spraying near the creeks feeding the reservoirs.
Where She Ate And What To Know Before You Go
For dinner she picked up a wood-fired pizza at Oakley’s, which she thought felt like a local spot, and she brought leftovers home for her husband, Tim, who arrived that night. By the next morning the pizza was gone.
Lunch was a veggie Reuben and avocado toast piled with arugula, and a beer at Arcville Brew Stillery was her boozy finale. Her Airbnb sat less than a mile from downtown, so she could walk into town.
- Plan for the drive, which was about two hours for her, and use the byway for stops.
- Book rail explorer tours early, since she found them full.
- Bring tick protection on hikes. She jokes that she and Tim check each other thoroughly.
She says she hopes the area can balance growing tourism with affordability for locals, because that seems to be the biggest challenge it faces.
More Stories You May Like
- 6 Ways to Protect Your Home and Retirement When Dating Later in Life Before You Move In Together or Merge Money Too Soon With a New Partner
- YouTubers Spend A Day In Bulls Gap Tennessee Population 750 And Find A 1969 Diner Serving A Spaghetti Salad And Bread Special For Just 9.99
- New York Smokehouse Offers Unlimited Ribs For Just $35 On Wednesdays But One Hungry Diner Says Most People Are Better Off Ordering A Half Rack

