The word on Memphis soul food spot Southern Hands is mixed. Some call it the best Southern cooking in town, and others have posted reviews that say the opposite. A food reviewer who goes by Saweetie Marie on @assaiyahmariee decided to form her own opinion.

She headed to the restaurant on New Branch Road, and from the videos she had seen, she says it looks like a cafeteria line. The food is already made, and you tell them what you want on your plate as you move down the line.
She says she had seen “pretty much mixed reviews,” but she planned to make up her own mind.
Her order was the lunch special with baked spaghetti, two sides of candied yams and greens, and a loaf of cornbread. She added a caramel cake and a fruit punch.
The Cashier Asked “Lunch Or Dinner?” And That One Question Saved Her $3
Before she could pay, the cashier asked whether she was ordering lunch or dinner. Lunch stops at 2:00, she learned, and it is cheaper.
The same baked spaghetti plate is $11.99 at lunch and $14.99 at dinner, she says. Her tip is to come at lunch if you want to save a few dollars.
Her total was $22.25 for the lunch special, the caramel cake and the fruit punch. The punch, she says, tastes like a Kool-Aid packet and is light on the sugar, though she says she did not mind it.
“It Is Very Much A Family-Owned Business,” But The Plate Got A Mixed Reaction Outside Lowe’s
Inside, she says, it is cute and clearly a family-run place, with a wide menu. She had considered the fried fish, but she says she had just reviewed the best catfish a couple of videos earlier.
She picked baked spaghetti because it is a classic Southern dish, and she says she wanted the candied yams as the test. “If you mess up on the candied yams, you might as well close up shop.”
They carried the food out and opened it in the car in the parking lot of a nearby Lowe’s. Her boyfriend looked at the plate and asked, “All that for $22?” Both of them agreed the spaghetti section could have been much fuller, and she asked viewers to weigh in on whether she got shortchanged.
The Spaghetti Surprised Her: “An Elite Grandma Spaghetti” That Belongs On The Side
She started with the spaghetti. It looked a little mid to her, with not much seasoning and a little pepper, and she says it looked and smelled like it was made with canned tomatoes.
Then she tasted it, and the verdict was kinder than she expected. “Not bad at all,” she says, calling it an “elite grandma spaghetti,” though nothing she would call the best spaghetti ever.
Her real problem is how it is being sold. She says it feels like a side to her, not a main order, and that if it is an entree it needs a bigger portion or something like sausage to bulk it up.
“It Came Out Of The Can,” She Says, Of The Candied Yams And The Turnip Greens
The yams were where the plate fell apart for her. They came with an odd brown piece on top that she and her boyfriend debated, with one guess that it was the end of a baked sweet potato.
She says the yams looked and tasted canned. The juice was light, and it did not smell like cinnamon, which is the sign she looks for.
The turnip greens got the same treatment. She says they did not look like they had been simmered in broth, and the light stems told her they had soaked in canning liquid. She says she does not even like turnip greens, but she thinks it was disrespectful to serve them as a soul food side. “I could have made this at home,” she says.
The Cornbread Looked Like Boxed Mix And The Caramel Cake Disappointed Too
The cornbread, she says, tasted like Jiffy mix with none of the usual tricks, such as a little sugar or honey on top. She says they just made the mix.
That left the caramel cake. She was nervous about trying it, because she suspected a store-bought cake. She says it tasted like box cake mix with caramel icing from the store, not something whipped up in a pan.
She says that for a place that calls itself Southern Hands, she hoped for real candied yams made the way a family would make them.
Her Verdict: “The Worst Soul Food In Memphis”
She put it bluntly. Everything on the plate, she says, was store-bought: cheap noodles, cheap tomato sauce, canned greens, canned yams, Jiffy mix and cake mix.
“The reviews are true,” she says. “This is literally the worst soul food in Memphis.” She called it a waste of time and money, like a quick weeknight meal made when you are not trying to do much.
It is only one reviewer’s visit, and the spaghetti earned some praise, but her overall take was harsh.
How To Size Up A Soul Food Spot Before You Order
Her trip points to a few easy habits when you are trying a new place:
- Ask whether lunch pricing is available. It can save a few dollars on the same plate.
- Judge a Southern spot by its candied yams, which she calls the test of a good kitchen.
- Look at portion size before you pay, since a plate that looks thin is hard to return.
- Read the mixed reviews and decide for yourself, as she did.
More Stories You May Like
- Restaurants Next To Famous Landmarks And Airport Gates Can Charge Top Dollar For Mediocre Food So Here Is How To Eat Where Locals Do
- Wedding Budget Creep Traps From Guest List Growth to While We Are at It Upgrades That Quietly Blow the Plan Before the Big Day
- Cooked Rice Left on the Counter Can Carry Bacteria That Survive Cooking and Cause Food Poisoning So Cool It Fast and Refrigerate Within Two Hours

