He thought he was being careful. After weeks of messaging a woman he had met on a dating app, a man recounted on Reddit that he suggested their first in-person meeting happen at a coffee shop or restaurant, somewhere public. Her reply was not a counter-suggestion. It was a 10-minute voice memo telling him he was “pulling her out of her feminine energy” and failing to lead like a “masculine man.” The post, which circulated widely on dating forums in early 2025, struck a nerve because it distilled a friction that has been building for years: the collision between self-help language about gender energy and the practical realities of safety, consent, and compatibility.
The phrases “feminine energy” and “masculine energy” have migrated from niche coaching circles into mainstream dating culture. On TikTok, the hashtag #feminineenergy has accumulated billions of views. Coaches like Sami Wunder and content creators across Instagram and YouTube teach women to “stay in their feminine” so that a partner will “step into his masculine” and take the lead. The advice has resonated with women who feel exhausted by the pressure to initiate, plan, and perform in both their careers and their love lives. But as the voice memo story illustrates, the same language can be weaponized to override boundaries and shut down reasonable conversation.
What “feminine energy” actually means, and what it doesn’t
In most coaching frameworks, feminine energy refers to a relational mode characterized by receptivity, emotional openness, and presence. Sami Wunder, a dating coach with a large online following, describes it as a state where a woman feels “relaxed, playful, and open, with a song on your lips,” as opposed to a task-driven mode that gets things done but can feel guarded in romance. Masculine energy, in this schema, maps onto qualities like decisiveness, direction, and protectiveness.
Licensed therapist Dawn Wiggins, who uses the framework in couples work, stresses that these are not gendered cages. “Both partners need access to both,” she writes in her overview of masculine and feminine energy in relationships. A woman can operate in masculine energy at work and shift into feminine energy at home, or vice versa. A man can be nurturing and intuitive without abandoning assertiveness. The model, Wiggins argues, is about flexibility, not prescription.
The concept has older roots than Instagram might suggest. Carl Jung wrote about the anima and animus, the feminine and masculine aspects present in every psyche, in the early 20th century. Modern polarity coaches draw loosely on that tradition, though most lack formal training in Jungian psychology. The gap between the therapeutic origin and the social media application is where much of the trouble starts.
The safety problem the voice memo exposed
Meeting a stranger from the internet in a public place is not a radical demand. The Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network (RAINN) lists public first meetings as a core online dating safety practice, alongside telling a friend where you will be and arranging your own transportation. Most dating apps include similar guidance in their safety sections.
In the Reddit poster’s account, his date reframed that precaution as a character flaw. By telling him he was “pulling her out of her feminine energy,” she cast his boundary as an obstacle to the dynamic she wanted, one in which he would confidently take charge and she would follow his lead. The framing left no room for his perspective. It converted a logistical preference into a moral failing.
This is the pattern that concerns relationship researchers. Dr. Lisa Bobby, a licensed marriage and family therapist and founder of Growing Self Counseling, has written about how pop psychology language can become “a tool for control rather than connection” when one partner uses therapeutic-sounding concepts to dismiss the other’s needs. The voice memo was not an invitation to negotiate. It was a verdict.
How polarity advice can slide into blame
Polarity coaches often argue that relationships thrive when one partner leans more heavily into masculine energy and the other into feminine. Some frameworks get granular, suggesting a person might operate at “60 to 80 percent dominant masculine energy,” as leadership coach Matteo Grosso describes in a LinkedIn essay on understanding masculine and feminine energies.
The trouble is not the metaphor itself. It is what happens when the metaphor becomes a script with only one acceptable outcome. Coaching content that tells women to “receive, not chase” and frames masculine energy as something that should naturally “pursue” feminine energy can create a rigid expectation: if he does not lead in exactly the way I envision, he is not masculine enough. That expectation leaves little space for the reality that people are complex, that leadership can look quiet, and that a man suggesting a coffee shop is not the same as a man refusing to show up.
Some voices within the polarity community acknowledge this risk. A guide on the site Saint Belford emphasizes that both partners need to feel safe and respected for any energetic dynamic to function. Emily Freeman, a feminine energy coach, lists the ability to “communicate desires directly and respond with compassion” as a sign of genuine integration into feminine energy, not passive compliance.
But nuance does not travel well on social media. A 60-second TikTok about “letting him lead” strips away the caveats. A 10-minute voice memo fueled by that content strips away the other person’s agency.
The overlap with the manosphere, and why it matters
It is worth noting that “masculine energy” rhetoric does not exist in a vacuum. On the other side of the internet, red-pill and manosphere communities use nearly identical language to argue that men should be dominant and women should be submissive. When a woman tells a man he is not being “masculine enough,” she may be drawing from coaching content that has more in common with traditionalist gender ideology than either side would like to admit.
That overlap does not mean everyone who talks about feminine energy is endorsing rigid gender roles. But it does mean the language carries baggage, and people using it in dating contexts should be aware of how it can land. A partner hearing “you’re not in your masculine” may hear an echo of the same online spaces that tell men their worth depends on dominance and control.
Using the framework without losing the person in front of you
For people who genuinely find the masculine-feminine energy model useful, therapists and thoughtful coaches offer a consistent piece of advice: use it as a mirror, not a measuring stick. Reflect on your own patterns. Notice when you feel open and when you feel guarded. But do not use the language to diagnose or discipline your partner.
The man in the Reddit story did not fail a masculinity test. He proposed a public meeting, a choice that most safety experts and most people with common sense would endorse. The woman who sent the voice memo may have been genuinely frustrated, but her framework gave her no vocabulary for that frustration beyond blame.
That is the real lesson of the 10-minute memo. The language of energy can help people understand themselves. But the moment it becomes a script for how someone else must behave, it stops being self-awareness and starts being coercion dressed in softer words.
“`
More from Cultivated Comfort:
- 7 Retro Home Features That Builders Should Bring Back
- 7 Antique Finds That Are Surprisingly Valuable Today
- 7 Forgotten Vacation Spots Your Parents Probably Loved
- 6 Boomer China Patterns That Are Selling Like Crazy Online
As a mom of three busy boys, I know how chaotic life can get — but I’ve learned that it’s possible to create a beautiful, cozy home even with kids running around. That’s why I started Cultivated Comfort — to share practical tips, simple systems, and a little encouragement for parents like me who want to make their home feel warm, inviting, and effortlessly stylish. Whether it’s managing toy chaos, streamlining everyday routines, or finding little moments of calm, I’m here to help you simplify your space and create a sense of comfort.
But home is just part of the story. I’m also passionate about seeing the world and creating beautiful meals to share with the people I love. Through Cultivated Comfort, I share my journey of balancing motherhood with building a home that feels rich and peaceful — and finding joy in exploring new places and flavors along the way.
