A slice of lime pie served on a white saucer.

A restaurant with a line out the door is either a great sign or a great way to waste an evening. For one couple filming a Florida food series at @thealtemlife, Salt Shack on the lake in downtown Clermont was a little of both.

A slice of lime pie served on a white saucer.

They say they had tried to eat there a couple of times before, and both times the long lines and long wait kept them from an easy meal, right when the doors opened. Salt Shack does not take reservations, so showing up and hoping is the only plan.

This time they finally ate there, and they came prepared. They were meeting the woman’s parents, who already had a table waiting.

The restaurant sits by the water near the historic village in downtown Clermont. They say there is a second Salt Shack location in Tampa.

“There’s Nowhere To Park On The Road,” But Free Public Lot Saves The Night

Parking comes first, because it is the first hurdle. The couple says there are only a few spots along the road and “you got to get lucky” to land one.

Their fix was the free public parking next to the water, a short walk from the restaurant. They add that a few spots may be available right behind the building too.

It was a chilly, windy evening, so the outdoor tables by the lake were out. The family chose to sit inside, where they were then told they would need jackets because it was cold in there too.

A Packed Friday Night Taught Them To Arrive At 5:45 Or Not At All

The couple got there at 5:45 on a Friday and were seated right away. An hour later, at 6:45, they say there was a waiting list and a crowd of people standing at the door.

Their tip: “get here as early as you can.” Even with open tables visible inside, the line kept growing, and when they finally left they could not believe how many people were waiting outside.

The menu reads like classic Florida waterfront. They saw wings, gator bites, oysters, clams and shrimp, a shrimp basket, soups and salads, burgers, a shark burger, tacos and a catch of the day, plus a bar of frozen drinks like a Shack piña colada and a Bahama Mama.

The Fries Came Out Tiny, But The Coconut Shrimp Was “Top-Notch”

The four of them ordered the island chicken tacos, a crab cake sandwich, the island grilled chicken and a coconut shrimp basket. The first thing that struck them was how small the sides were. One diner counted exactly four fries on a plate.

The fries were not crispy, though the creator says the seasoning was very good. She is a crispy-fry fan, so that stung a little.

The shrimp was another story. She called it “top-notch,” with a light coating of sweet coconut flakes and a citrus mustard sauce that tasted just like it sounds.

The tacos were fine, but she says they needed a sauce. Her advice was to add ranch for more flavor. Another diner said his food needed the sauce too, and he asked for the horseradish to be left off.

The Waiter Said Key Lime Pie Was “By Far” The Best Dessert, And He Was Right

When the couple asked about dessert, the waiter listed Key lime pie, chocolate pie and rum cake. He said “by far” the best was the Key lime pie.

That was enough for them. They ordered one slice for the table, and it arrived fast and looking homemade.

The verdict: “That is actually a very good Key lime pie.” It was not super tart, and she called it the best thing of the whole night, even better than her shrimp. Next to the tiny sides that let the table down, the Key lime pie was the clear winner and outshone them easily.

Even A Key Lime Skeptic At The Table Called It The Best Slice She Had Eaten

The pie won over people who did not expect to like it. One diner says she is not a big Key lime pie lover, and she half jokes that her Florida card might be taken away, but she still called it a good one that was worth ordering after the meal.

Her mother, who says she is not a fan either, took a bite and called it the best Key lime pie she has probably ever had. She also loved her grilled island chicken, served with rice and peas, two asparagus spears and plantains, and she was pleased with her sides.

The Bill Came To About $91.50 For Four Entrees, A Dessert And Two Teas

The couple says the total was around $91.50, which covered four entrees, one dessert and two teas. They call that a little on the high side, though not outrageous compared with other places they have been.

Prices do not seem to scare off the crowd. The room stayed packed all night, and they point out that you are getting seafood on the water in downtown Clermont.

They also note the meal took a good while, with the food taking a bit to come out. Even so, the family agreed the location is great and the food was worth the trip.

How To Do Salt Shack Right

Based on their evening, a few moves make the visit smoother:

  • Arrive early, especially on a Friday, since there are no reservations.
  • Use the free public lot by the water instead of hunting for a street spot.
  • Bring a jacket on a windy evening, even if you plan to eat indoors.
  • Order sauce with the tacos and save room for the Key lime pie.
  • Expect modest sides and plan your order around the mains.

The creators closed by thanking the viewer who suggested the spot and asking others to share what they like to order there.

More Stories You May Like

+ posts

Similar Posts