An aerial view of a resort swimming pool in Cancun.

After almost two decades of cruising and around 50 voyages, @CruisingKat finally tried her first all-inclusive resort, in Cancun. Somewhere along the way, she says, she realized she may have been looking at vacations completely wrong.

An aerial view of a resort swimming pool in Cancun.

The first thing that surprised her was what “all-inclusive” really means. Her room, food, drinks, pools and beach were part of the price, but plenty of other things were not.

The Resort Had The Same Shops, Spa Charges And Paid Extras Cruisers Gripe About

There were shops all over the property selling everything from T-shirts and swimsuits to jewelry and watches. There was a spa where she could spend plenty of extra money, and some activities and experiences carried additional charges.

She has heard people complain for years that cruise lines nickel-and-dime passengers with shops, spas and specialty restaurants. After her stay, she says, “I don’t think they’re actually that different in that respect.” She asked her audience whether extra spending is normal at all-inclusives, since this was the only one she has stayed at.

She personally does not mind either way. If she wants a massage she is glad there is a spa, and if she forgets a swimsuit she is glad there is a store. “Having something available to me to buy doesn’t mean I have to buy it.”

Where The Resort Beat The Ship Hands Down

She is quick to give credit where it is due. Her standard room was huge compared with a normal cruise cabin, with an ocean view balcony and a big bathroom. You can get that kind of space on a ship, she notes, but then you are looking at a suite, which can dramatically change the price.

The pools were enormous too. Cruise ship pools are small, even on gigantic new ships, because there is only so much space and water weight a top deck can carry. And then there was the beach, right outside. You do not wait for a ship to dock, find transportation, pay for a beach club or worry about being back on board.

“If your idea of a perfect vacation is waking up, walking down to the beach, spending a few hours there, moving over to the massive pool, and doing it all again tomorrow, I get it now.”

“How Much Of That Is Worth It To Me?”

Then she started asking what those features were actually worth to her. She lived in Florida for almost 10 years and says they rarely went to the beach after a while. She also has a pool at home, so enormous pools are not something she wants to pay a huge premium for on vacation.

Other people do want that, she adds, and that is what they want to do on vacation. Her realization was that comparing which trip has the better amenities does not answer the question she thought it did.

She Does Not Buy The “Same Ports” Complaint

One thing people say about cruising is that you wake up somewhere different every morning. She says that is not really why she loves it. She wants to go somewhere new, and the ship simply moves her hotel room from destination to destination while she sleeps. She can go to bed after a day in Italy and wake up in France or Spain.

When someone says cruises always visit the same ports, her first thought is to ask which cruises they are looking at. Repeating short sailings from Florida means hello, Nassau, every time. But there are also Alaska, Europe, Hawaii, Asia, Australia and river cruises across Europe.

She also notes that an all-inclusive does not automatically bring deeper cultural immersion just because you slept in Mexico for five or six nights. That, she says, is a different conversation from true independent land travel.

One Guest Saw Fewer Choices As Relaxing, She Saw Them As Limiting

At the resort she chatted with another guest who said he does not like all the scheduling on ships, with shows, activities, dining times and excursions all day. To him that sounded stressful, not relaxing.

She had always thought, “You don’t have to do any of this.” A cruise compass listing 25 things does not mean she must do 25. On some cruises she has done absolutely nothing. As they talked, though, she understood what he meant. He liked waking up and knowing the day was pool, beach, food and a drink.

She was looking around and wondering what else she could do. The resort did have little kayaks to paddle on the pool, which she thought was cool, but nothing close to what even smaller, older ships offer. And when she called Kevin back home, he asked, “What would I do?” He likes volleyball, dodgeball and mini golf with friends and does not enjoy sitting by the pool.

Why A $3,000 Resort And A $3,000 Cruise Are Not The Same Value

She compares it to her father-in-law, who restores antique cars from the 1940s and 1950s. Put one of those next to a brand new sports car at the same price, and which is better? “The question is to whom?”

The same goes for a $3,000 resort and a $3,000 cruise. The price alone tells you almost nothing about value. What matters is what you are getting that you actually care about.

Drinks are not exclusive to resorts either. Most mainstream cruise lines sell drink packages, and loyalty programs and casino perks can include drinks. She watches fares for clients and says she has seen a nice ship with a great itinerary and a drink package still come out competitive with a nice all-inclusive resort.

There is also the question of getting there. Cruise ports are all over the US, so you might drive or take a cheap domestic flight, but beach all-inclusives are mostly in Mexico or the Caribbean, which means international airfare, transfers and sometimes an extra travel day.

Was She Wrong? “Kind Of, But Not The Way I Expected”

She still prefers cruising. The resort did not make her feel she had been vacationing wrong for 20 years. What changed was how she compares them. She used to treat the two as cousins, with rooms, food, drinks and pools, and the ship simply adding more. Now she sees that if you want to settle into one beautiful place with no hundred decisions to make, more is not necessarily better.

“I thought I was comparing vacations, but what we should really be comparing is mindsets.” Her advice is that everyone should try cruising at least once, but choose that first ship carefully, since a small quiet ship is a very different experience from a giant ship packed with activities.

More Stories You May Like

+ posts

Similar Posts