Every steak lover has a secret order, and one TikTok diner thinks his is the best thing on the Texas Roadhouse menu. His pick is an 11-ounce sirloin, cooked medium rare and “Pittsburgh.” The internet had opinions about that sentence before the steak even hit the table.

The story comes from BroBible, which tracked down the man behind the video and asked Texas Roadhouse to weigh in.
“Can I Get The 11-Ounce Hand-Cut Sirloin? Cooked Medium Rare And Pittsburgh, Please?”
The diner goes by Bubba, and he posts on TikTok as @bubbahpaints. In the clip, which has racked up more than 1.9 million views, he settles in at a Texas Roadhouse table while the server comes over to take the order.
He asks for the 11-ounce hand-cut sirloin, medium rare, with one extra request that he says takes it up a notch. “Can I get the 11-ounce hand-cut sirloin? Cooked medium rare and Pittsburgh, please?” he tells the server.
When the plate arrives, the outside looks dark and charred. “It’s got a crust,” says the woman filming.
Bubba picks up his knife and cuts into it. The middle is exactly the medium rare he asked for, and his verdict is a satisfied “Oh, yeah.”
“‘Best Steak’ And Then Orders A Sirloin”
If Bubba expected a round of applause, he did not get one. Commenters jumped on the choice of cut first, and they did not go easy on him.
“‘Best steak’ and then orders a sirloin,” one wrote. Another said, “Best steak and sirloin do not belong in the same sentence.” A third chimed in, “Buddy said best steak at Texas Roadhouse then ordered a sirloin.”
Then came the second wave, and this one was about the wording of the order itself. Plenty of viewers insisted that “medium rare” and “Pittsburgh” are two different ideas that cannot share a sentence.
“There’s no ‘medium rare and Pittsburgh’ it’s one of the other,” one person said. Another asked, “How do you ask for medium rare and Pittsburgh,” and a third guessed the cook “just laughed” when the ticket came in.
The Steel Mill Story Behind A Burnt-On-Purpose Steak
So what is Pittsburgh style, anyway? One commenter offered a colorful history lesson. Pittsburgh was a big iron and steel town, the commenter explained, and workers cooked steaks they brought to work on red-hot metal, which scorched the outside while leaving the inside rare.
It makes a great story, though the article points out that it is only one theory. According to FoodRepublic, the true origin of the style is ambiguous, and the theories range from that steel mill tale to a restaurant cook who simply burned a steak and decided to run with it.
What everyone agrees on is the look. FoodRepublic describes Pittsburgh style as meat charred so hard on the outside that it looks like a crust of black coal, with an inside that is barely warmed and borderline raw. The Daily Meal says the style can also go by the name “black and blue.”
The appeal, per those reports, is the contrast. The outside is rough, bitter and smoky from an aggressive sear, while the inside stays bright pink and tender. Fans of the style say that duality is the whole point, and some believe it is the only way to eat a steak.
Bubba And Texas Roadhouse Both Weigh In
Bubba told BroBible this is how he usually orders, and he says he never runs into trouble. “It’s usually how I order it, but I don’t always get sirloin. The server is the one that told us about it years ago and at Texas Roadhouse you can get it any temp,” he said.
He also explained what he believes “Pittsburgh” means at this particular chain. “The ‘Pittsburgh’ is more the extra seasoning on the outside that creates a crust it’s Texas Roadhouse it’s not a chef driven steakhouse,” he said.
Texas Roadhouse gave BroBible a statement that lines up with his experience. “If a guest orders a steak Pittsburgh style, we cook it the traditional way in a cast-iron skillet, creating that signature char on the outside. While Pittsburgh-style steak is traditionally served rare, at Texas Roadhouse we cook it to the guest’s preferred temperature,” the company said.
In other words, the restaurant treats “Pittsburgh” as a way to build the crust and lets the guest pick the doneness. That is exactly the combination Bubba asked for.
As for the pile-on, Bubba is taking it in stride. He says he and his wife, who also goes viral on TikTok, get bashed often. “You have to have a thick skin and realize even if the comments are nasty, it’s still another view,” he said.
What To Know Before You Order A Steak Your Own Way
This little food fight holds a handy lesson for anyone who likes to customize a restaurant order. Steakhouse terms do not mean exactly the same thing from one kitchen to the next, so a quick question can save you from a surprise.
- Ask the server how the kitchen defines a style before you order it. Bubba says a server at Texas Roadhouse is the one who first told him about this option.
- Remember that doneness words describe the inside of the meat, including its color and temperature once it is cut. A crust or char describes the outside, so the two can work together if the restaurant allows it.
- Know your cut. Sirloin is a leaner, budget-friendly cut, so it behaves differently on the grill than a richly marbled ribeye. Pick the cut that fits the flavor you want.
- If you are cooking at home, a meat thermometer takes the guesswork out. Food safety guidance for whole cuts of beef is 145 degrees Fahrenheit, so if you like yours rarer, that is a personal choice you make with eyes open.
At the end of the day, the best steak is the one you enjoy. Bubba liked his sirloin, his crust and his medium-rare middle, and the kitchen delivered what he asked for. The rest of the internet can argue about the vocabulary.
More Stories You May Like
- Mom Leaves Her Daughter’s Stuffed Animals, Jacket, Wallet And Car Keys At The Table For 3 Minutes, Comes Back To Find A Diner Bartender Tossed Them In The Trash
- Landlord Rents To A Tenant Who Used Her Cousin’s Info On The Application, Keeps Forgiving Late Rent For Two Years, Then The Tenant Vanishes And Animal Control Calls About What She Left Behind
- 9 Of America’s Oldest Towns Worth A Road Trip, Where Centuries Of History Are Still Standing Right On Main Street

