Landlord shares her rental property horror story about a tenant who used her cousin's information, next to a brick house with a front door

Owning a rental property sounds like a dream until a tenant story goes sideways. A New York landlord who posts as @katielucillewrites owns three rental properties, and she says one of them has been such a horrible experience that she may never want another.

Landlord shares her rental property horror story about a tenant who used her cousin's information, next to a brick house with a front door

It began with a tenant who used a cousin’s information on her application. Two years later it ended with a call from animal control.

@katielucillewrites

The Application Looked Easy, Until A Stranger Texted “She Used A Fake ID”

She found the tenant through the Zillow application, which runs credit scores and background checks. She says it was so easy to use.

About a month later, she got a text from a random number. The sender said he was the tenant’s boyfriend, that her name was actually something different, and that she had used a fake ID. He wanted to let the landlord know because she seemed nice.

She says that is how she learned the tenant had given her cousin’s information, which was what got run through Zillow.

A Sob Story, A Single Mom, And A Landlord Who Did Not Want To Evict

When the couple broke up, the landlord contacted the tenant. She says she got a whole sob story: the tenant was a single mom, and said a man had laid hands on her. The tenant had also paid every dollar owed so far.

The landlord felt bad. Her response was that as long as the tenant kept paying, they were fine. In her own words, it was really her being lazy about not wanting to go through an eviction when she should have.

For about six months the rent came in. Then the tenant got a little behind, and more sob stories followed.

“When Tax Returns Hit, I Will Pay You”

By the end of the first year, the tenant was two months behind. She promised to pay when her tax return arrived, and the landlord says she did. It was stressful, but she got all of her money.

The tenant was also easy about repairs. If something broke in the house, she was always polite and chill about it, which the landlord says is huge for anyone who has rented out property.

So she went with the devil she knew over the devil she did not, and let the tenant stay another year.

A Second Year Of Spreadsheets, Excuses And Christmas Decorations

Immediately, she says, it was worse. She was playing catch up every month and kept a spreadsheet to track how much had been paid.

The tenant stayed pleasant, though. She sent photos of the house decorated for Christmas and Halloween, and the landlord told herself that as long as the home was being cared for, it was fine. She admits she made all kinds of justifications.

At the end of the second year, the tenant used the same tax return line again. This time she was three months behind.

The Phone Call Would Not Go Through, And The Police Found An Empty House

The tenant did not answer her last text. When the landlord called, it did not even go through. She texted again, and the message came up green.

She asked police to do a wellness check. They told her it looked like the tenant had just left. No one was inside, there was some furniture, but the tenant had packed up.

The landlord lives in New York and the house is in Dallas, so she could not simply drive over. She arranged for her contractor to go look at the property.

Two Days Later, Dallas Animal Control Called About The Backyard

Before the contractor could go, the city of Dallas called from 311 animal control. They told her a dog had been howling in the backyard for about a week, that it now smelled really bad, and that they believed there was a dead dog on her property.

She says animal control would not go into the backyard because it was fenced off. They also would not collect the animal from the property, and the dog had to be dragged to the front yard.

She sent her contractor, whom she calls a saint, and paid him a lot of money for the job because she felt horrible. She says the dog was covered in maggots and he held his breath the whole time while he dragged it to the front yard for 311 to clear away.

“All Mistakes I Made, But Also Very Valuable Lessons”

All along, she says, she believed she was helping a struggling single mom. Instead, she says, the tenant abandoned her dog, kept in a cage in the backyard, and left it to die.

The experience has her unsure about buying another rental property. She calls it scarring, says the mistakes were hers, and says she learned more from it than from any course she has paid for.

What Small Landlords Can Take From Her Story

Her own list of regrets points to some sound habits for anyone renting out a home. The details of landlord and tenant law vary by state, so check your local rules before acting.

  • Verify identity yourself. She says the applicant’s information belonged to a cousin. Asking to see photo ID and matching it to the application is a basic safeguard.
  • Enforce the lease from the start. She says she should have upheld the contract harder, and that letting late rent slide only made each month worse.
  • Keep a payment record. Her spreadsheet got her through the second year, and a written log protects you if a dispute lands in court.
  • Do not let a good story replace the lease. Sympathy is natural, but she says her decisions came from not wanting to deal with an eviction.
  • Line up local help. When you own a property in another city, having a trusted contractor on call mattered a great deal for her.

She finishes by saying that if you want to buy rental properties, you should go for it, but her story shows the cost of looking the other way.

More Stories You May Like

+ posts

Similar Posts