A cappuccino with latte art served in a cup on a saucer.

Harry Styles ended a 30-show run at Madison Square Garden with a joke about the scariest thing in New York on Halloween. It was not a ghost or a goblin. It was the price of a cup of coffee.

A cappuccino with latte art served in a cup on a saucer.

The New York Post reports that the singer, dressed as Elvis Presley, told the crowd that city cappuccinos and the tip screens that follow them have gotten out of hand.

“It Is A Cappuccino. It Can’t Be $10, It Can’t Be!”

Fans who paid hundreds of dollars to see him on Halloween heard the speech, which was captured and shared on social media. “New York, we love you. The scariest thing about this Halloween is the price of caffeinated beverages in this city. Astronomical. It’s out of control. They have to be stopped,” Styles said to roars of cheers.

Then he got specific. “It is a cappuccino. It can’t be $10, it can’t be!” he said.

The tip prompt got its turn next. “And then they spin it around at me, and it’s a 22% or 24% [tip]. It’s out of control,” Styles said.

It was a funny moment for a night built around costumes, and the crowd treated it that way. But the idea of a tip prompt popping up for a simple coffee struck a nerve outside the arena, too, and the Post went looking for reactions.

New Yorkers Fire Back: “If He Can Afford To Stay In Tribeca”

The crowd cheered, but plenty of New Yorkers on the street did not. Angie Deleon, a 19-year-old college student who buys a $6 coffee every day, said tipping is about appreciation. “Tipping is showing your appreciation for the server, whether it’s a $10 cup of coffee or you are at a restaurant,” she said.

She added a comparison from the nightlife world. “My friends, when they go to the nightclub and get bottle service, one person will tip $300 if the bill is $1,000 or more,” she said.

Then she turned to where the singer is reportedly living, an $8.71 million luxury loft on Greenwich Street in Tribeca. “If he can afford to stay in Tribeca, tipping shouldn’t be an issue for him,” she said.

“I Always Make Sure I Do 15%”

Ronald Romero-Henley, a 21-year-old food service worker, said it was “shocking” to hear a celebrity complain about $10. He and his wife weigh whether to buy Starbucks, which he noted is not even $10, or invest in something they need.

He believes tipping should be a given and said the singer came across like a “spoiled person.” Then he offered his own rule. “I always make sure I do 15%. Harry Styles can do 100%,” he said.

“I think his lifestyle of the rich and famous — he is an icon in the entertainment industry — probably makes him think he doesn’t have to,” he added.

Michael Wayman, a 31-year-old chef, gave Styles a little grace. He guessed the singer may have been “having a bad day” but said he had no ground to stand on. “He can buy a $10 cup of coffee 10 million times,” Wayman said.

The tipping comments were what bothered him most. “That turns me off. I’m not going to be listening to his music anymore,” he said.

The Numbers Behind The Joke

The Post pointed out some context. Ticket prices for the shows started at $349, and specialty packages for the 30-night run went for as much as $1,000. The entire tour grossed an estimated $200 million.

The paper also noted that the “$10” cappuccino is a tough find. Chains like Blank Street and Starbucks sell the espresso and steamed milk drink for $6.12 and $5.45, respectively.

Elvis, the costume of the night, comes with its own tipping tale. The King of Rock ‘n’ Roll was known to be generous and famously tipped a waitress $5,000 after a meal and a few beers. The Post says that is nearly $54,000 in today’s money.

Styles may not be wrong about prices in general. Coffee costs have surged in recent years, with a pound of ground roast coffee in U.S. cities averaging $9.33 in September, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. That is the highest ever for the month and 91% higher than in 2020.

All of it adds up to a debate that goes well beyond one singer. Prices are climbing, tip screens are everywhere, and plenty of people feel caught between wanting to be generous and wanting to keep their budgets intact.

How To Handle Tip Screens Without Feeling Squeezed

Even if you are not selling out arenas, that spin-around screen can make anyone flinch. A few ideas can help you feel in charge of your own money.

  • You are not stuck with the default buttons. Most screens have a custom option where you can enter your own dollar amount or percentage.
  • Decide ahead of time what feels fair for a quick counter order. Some people tip a dollar or two on a coffee, and others leave nothing. That is a personal call.
  • Compare prices before you buy. As the Post noted, the same drink can cost a few dollars less at a different chain.
  • Make coffee at home a few days a week. With coffee prices up sharply since 2020, a good home brew saves real money.

Styles got his laughs, and New Yorkers got their say. Both sides agree on one thing, a $10 cappuccino is a lot to swallow.

More Stories You May Like

+ posts

Similar Posts