Pizza is supposed to be the easy, affordable meal in New York, so when a customer says he paid $68 plus tax for a whole pie, people notice. Creator @soberfacts filmed a candid review outside a pizzeria in Manhattan’s Little Italy that he names as Ceres, and his bottom line was blunt: it was regular pizza, and in his opinion not worth the price.
Before we go further, a fair note: this is one customer’s opinion about one visit. Plenty of diners may feel differently, and the video itself includes a surprising admission that we will get to below.
What the Creator Says Happened
According to the creator, the restaurant sells whole pies for about $68 and does not sell individual slices. He says he waited around 50 minutes to get his order. He also says staff shared a story about the restaurant’s history, going back to 1940 and involving a grandmother and grandfather in a backyard. We cannot verify that history, but it gives a sense of the brand the restaurant is leaning on.
He was not happy that kids, in particular, cannot just walk up and buy a slice. His frustration also spilled into bigger complaints about prices in general, and he said he feels squeezed from many directions. He added that he had been “scammed” by five restaurants that week, which is his own characterization of his week and not a finding about any business.
The Taste Test
Here is the twist. When he finally tried the pizza, he said it did not taste bad. His issue was never that the pie was awful. His point was that, to him, it was an ordinary pizza with nothing special about it, and that it was overpriced for what he got. The caption calls it “regular pizza” and says it was definitely not worth $68 plus tax.
How Viewers Reacted
Reaction in the comments was mixed. One viewer agreed the pizza is good and different, but called $70 for a pie “nasty work,” meaning in their view the price is hard to justify. Another wanted the creator to keep calling out trendy businesses that, in their opinion, are not catering to authentic New York.
Some commenters also criticized how the video ended, with a couple saying he should have given the pizza away instead of tossing it on the ground. We cannot confirm what happened off camera, but it shows how strongly people feel about both food prices and food waste.
Why Some Pizza Costs So Much
A $68 pizza sounds shocking next to the classic dollar slice, but a few general factors often push prices up at destination restaurants. Rent in tourist heavy neighborhoods can be steep. Ingredient costs, labor and imported items such as specialty cheeses and flour can add up. Some restaurants also price themselves as a sit down experience, not a quick bite, and a big name can bring long lines. Whether those things justify a higher price is a personal call.
Smart Ways to Judge Pizza Value
If you are tempted by a pricey pie, or just trying to feed a family without overspending, these ideas can help. They are general tips, not a verdict on any one restaurant.
- Ask about slices before you wait. The creator says this spot does not sell slices. A quick call or a look at the menu online can save you nearly an hour in line.
- Check the size. A pie can be anywhere from a personal size to a big family size. Ask the diameter and how many slices to expect, then work out a price per slice.
- Compare with the neighborhood. Look at what a few nearby pizzerias charge for a comparable pie so you know whether you are paying for the food, the location or the name.
- Look at what is on it. Premium toppings and imported ingredients can raise the cost. A plain cheese pie at a premium price is worth a second thought.
- Factor in the extras. Tax, service charges and delivery fees can nudge a bill higher, so check the final total before you commit.
- Decide what you are paying for. If the story, the setting and the experience matter to you, a splurge may be fun. If you simply want a great dinner, a local favorite might serve you better.
In the end, the creator said it himself: the pizza did not taste bad, it just was not worth the price to him. That might be the most useful takeaway of all. Value is personal, and the best slice, or pie, is the one you feel good about paying for.
More from Cultivated Comfort
- She Got A $600 Tip On A $600 Tab, Cried, Left Early, And Picked Up A Monday Shift Hoping Her Luck Would Continue
- Her Restaurant Bill Had A 4 Percent Health Charge, Supposedly To Cover Staff Health Insurance, And She Is Not Buying It
- Central Pennsylvania Barbecue Owner Says His Food Costs Are Up About 20 Percent Amid Higher Diesel Costs And Fuel Surcharges, And Your Plate Could Be Next
