Every Thanksgiving potluck has one: the deviled egg platter that looks lovely and disappears in about four minutes. One mom has had enough, and she is telling everyone exactly how many to make.

“If you sign up to bring deviled eggs for Thanksgiving, you should be bringing at least a hundred deviled eggs,” says @jaxicole_momlife in a video she captioned “If you gone make the eggs, MAKE ENOUGH!!!”
@jaxicole_momlife
“That’s Not Enough” Is Her Verdict On The Dollar Tree Platter
Her complaint is simple. Unless your family dinner is only four or five people, she asks, why are you showing up with “that little Dollar Tree tray” holding 14 or 15 eggs?
“That’s not enough,” she says, and she says it twice for emphasis. If you are feeding 20-something people, she says, you should automatically have a hundred deviled eggs.
“People Eat Two, Three, Four Deviled Eggs At A Time”
She has heard the other side of the argument, and she has an answer. People worry the eggs will go to waste, she says, but they will not.
“People gonna pack them up and take them home,” she says. She points out that guests typically eat two, three or even four at a time, and that is before anyone goes back for seconds.
It is a hard point to argue with if you have ever stood at a buffet table watching the egg plate empty first.
The Math Gets Worse At Forty People
Then she runs the numbers on the skimpy platter. Fifteen eggs for 25 or 30 people, she says, is not going to work. Fifteen eggs for 40 people is worse.
Imagine the scene as she describes it. The cook who brought 15 might have eaten four or five of them before even arriving. The rest of the room, she says, sees a small platter and 40 hungry guests, and some of those guests never get a single egg.
Her advice for anyone who volunteers: “Go ahead and prepare yourself and get a big box of them eggs and make you about a hundred deviled eggs for Thanksgiving.” Her closing line is just as direct: “Stop being skimpy.”
Her message in short: it is better to have too many than too few. When the host is feeding a crowd, she says, “100 eggs” on the table beats 15 every time.
So How Many Eggs Does A Hundred Deviled Eggs Really Take?
Here is the kitchen math that might make the challenge feel less scary. Each hard-boiled egg makes two deviled egg halves, and when people say they ate “one deviled egg” they usually mean one half.
A dozen eggs makes 24 halves. So a hundred halves works out to about 50 whole eggs, or just over four dozen.
That is a lot of boiling, but it is not impossible. A big pot, a timer and a long counter can get you there in an afternoon.
How To Make A Big Batch Without Losing Your Mind
If you have decided to take her advice, a few tips from experienced hosts can make the job easier. None of them are fancy.
- Boil the eggs a day ahead and keep them in the refrigerator in their shells. Peeling is easier when they have chilled.
- Mix the filling the night before and spoon it into a zip-top bag, then snip a corner to pipe it quickly.
- Keep deviled eggs cold. Food safety guidance says perishable food should not sit out for more than two hours, and less in hot rooms.
- Carry them in a container with a lid, and have a tray ready for the table.
- If you are short on time, ask a friend to share the load and each make fifty halves.
Flavor matters as much as quantity. Classic mustard, mayonnaise and a sprinkle of paprika please most tables, and you can set aside a small plate for a spicier version if you like. Making one big batch of filling keeps every egg tasting the same.
It also pays to plan your platter. A large, flat serving dish holds many more halves than a small tray, and a second dish waiting in the refrigerator lets you refill the table when the first one empties.
A Friendly Rule For Every Potluck Signup Sheet
Her rant is funny, but it points to a real rule of good potluck manners. If you sign up to bring something, bring enough for the crowd, or tell the host how many servings you plan to bring.
Hosts often count on a single dish to cover one part of the meal. A small tray of the most popular item can leave guests disappointed, while a large one makes everyone feel looked after.
And if you cannot make a hundred, say so ahead of time. Maybe somebody else can cover the rest, and the egg lovers at the table will be grateful you spoke up.
Thanksgiving is about sharing, and nobody can share an egg that is not there. So this year, boil a few extra dozen, and nobody has to go home thinking about the one deviled egg they missed.
More Stories You May Like
- 92-Year-Old Spends $120 On Thanksgiving Food For Six People And Plans 14 Dishes To Feed Everyone Thursday Through Monday, Says It Is Almost What She Spends In A Month
- Stove Top, Breakfast Sausage And Cranberry Pepper Jelly Turn Into Thanksgiving Sausage Balls With No Precooking, Though The Cook Promised 30 And Only Got 27
- This Mash Up Of Mashed Potatoes And Stuffing Starts With Stale Bread And Turkey Stock, Bakes Up With A Cheesy Top, And Ends As A Thanksgiving Freaking Classic

