Money left on a restaurant table after a meal, as a diner weighs the tip.

A man stood at an Applebee’s payment kiosk, looked at the screen, and saw a suggested tip of $11.30 on a $49.49 bill. Then he did something plenty of us wish we did more often: he pulled out his phone and checked the math.

Money left on a restaurant table after a meal, as a diner weighs the tip.

What he found, which he shared in a TikTok video under the handle @jdmacias77, did not add up the way he expected. A 20% tip on $49.49 comes to $9.90, which is about $1.40 less than the amount the kiosk was offering.

@jdmacias77

The Kiosk’s $11.30 Matched A Different Total Than The Food Bill

So where did $11.30 come from? The after-tax total on that check was $56.50, and 20% of $56.50 works out to exactly $11.30. The machine appeared to be figuring its suggestion on the total with tax already added, not on the $49.49 subtotal for the food and drinks.

The difference between those two totals is $7.01. That is the chunk of the bill the kiosk was counting as tippable money.

According to his video, the payment screen did say that tips were calculated after tax and before discounts. So the explanation was there on the screen, but only for a customer who stopped to read it while a line formed behind him.

“It’s Only $1.40” Is Where Most Of Us Stop Checking

On a single dinner, $1.40 is not going to ruin anyone’s week, and nobody should lose sleep over it. But a kiosk suggestion is a default, and defaults are built for the customer who taps the biggest friendly-looking button and moves along.

Try the same exercise at the lower buttons. On the $49.49 subtotal, 15% is about $7.42 and 18% is about $8.91. On the $56.50 after-tax total, those same percentages come to about $8.48 and $10.17.

Every button on the screen is a little higher than the same percentage on the food total. The gap is small each time, and it is there each time.

Tip On The Tax? Etiquette Guides Have Long Said No

To be fair, tipping on the after-tax total is not unheard of, and plenty of generous diners do it on purpose. Many etiquette guides, though, have long said the tip belongs on the pre-tax amount, since tax is a government charge and not part of the service your server provided.

Nothing in the video accuses the server of anything. The question he raised is about the setting behind the screen, and about whether customers know which number their percentage is working from.

Restaurant payment systems generally let the business choose how suggested tips are calculated. That means two restaurants using similar kiosks can show two different suggestions for the very same meal, and neither screen will look wrong to a hurried guest.

A Phone Calculator Beat The Kiosk, And It Took Ten Seconds

The charm of this story is how ordinary it is. There was no dramatic argument, no manager called over, no scene in the dining room. A customer saw a number that felt a bit high, tested it on his phone, and talked about what he found.

That small habit is worth borrowing. Restaurant bills have gotten more complicated, with service charges, fees and suggested percentages all landing on one small screen, and a few seconds of arithmetic keeps you in charge of what you leave.

How To Tip The Amount You Actually Mean To Leave

Start with the receipt before you reach the kiosk. Find the subtotal line, the one that comes before tax, and note it. That is the number most people think of when they say “twenty percent.”

Here is a quick way to do the math in your head. Move the decimal one place to find 10%, then double it for 20%. On $49.49, 10% is about $4.95, so 20% is about $9.90, which matches the figure in the video.

Most kiosks and card readers also have a “custom” or “other” button. Tap it and type in your own dollar amount, and the screen will take your number instead of its own.

If you would rather tip on the after-tax total, that is a perfectly fine choice. The point is that it should be your choice, made on purpose, and not something a default decided for you.

If a screen ever looks confusing, you can ask your server for the itemized check, or ask how the suggested amounts are figured. A friendly question at the table is easier than a puzzled look at the car.

And if you are paying with a group, have one person do the arithmetic out loud before anyone taps a button. A table of six can easily add a few dollars to a tip without anybody noticing, simply because the first person tapped the top option and everyone else followed.

The Bottom Line On An $11.30 Suggestion

An $11.30 suggestion on a $49.49 bill is not a scandal, and no one in this story is a villain. It is a reminder that the percentages on a payment screen are only as good as the number they start from.

Check the subtotal, check the percentage, and tip what you truly intend. Servers work hard for the money they earn, and being generous is wonderful, but you should always know exactly what you are being generous with.

More Stories You May Like

+ posts

Similar Posts