Costco’s return policy has a legendary reputation. Shoppers brag about it, and plenty of members treat it like an insurance plan. One Arizona man decided to test it with a big flat screen, and the result went viral for a surprising reason.

The TikToker, who posts as @kinghillbilly69, filmed the whole trip. BroBible covered the video, and the comments quickly turned into a debate about who was actually in the right.
A TV That “Just Stopped Working”
In the video, the man says his TV “just stopped working.” He loads the large flat screen onto a flatbed cart and rolls it toward the “Refunds Entry Only” sign.
Before he reaches the counter, a female staff member walks up and tells him the policy does not apply to “major appliances” bought more than 90 days ago. He waits in line anyway, and as he does, the camera pans to the policy posted on the wall. It restates the satisfaction guarantee, but the sign also lists exceptions.
The Cashier Said No, Politely, With A Printed Sheet
At the counter, the shopper repeats what he was told outside. The cashier confirms she was correct and says the policy has a “limit” on electrical goods.
The customer explains what happened. He says he was in the middle of a movie when lines appeared on the screen and then it turned white. He adds that he still has Roku TVs working 10 years later.
The employee says he will try to help, then confirms the TV was bought in 2024. Because of that, he says he cannot take it back. He tells the man that if he had bought the manufacturer’s warranty, he could have returned it.
The employee hands over a printed sheet and says Warranty Technical Services may be able to help “troubleshoot” or fix the television. Any store credit, he adds, would be at the discretion of Costco’s corporate team. For next time, he says, buy the warranty.
“They Were Mean To Me And My Son”
Then the employee notices the man’s son filming and asks him to stop. Later in the video, the TikToker is shown loading a new TV into his car.
In the video description, he wrote, “Went to Costco for their awesome return policy but then they were mean to me and my son.”
BroBible says it reached out to the TikToker by Facebook message and to Costco through its contact form.
The Comments Were Not On His Side
Most viewers did not see the meanness he described. “This has to be satire,” one wrote. “That man’s customer service was top notch.”
“Who … was mean to you and your son?” a second asked. “Just because he told you to please stop recording?” A third said, “That was the most professional service the guy could have given you. He was honest, polite, courteous, and explained everything very well. Not sure what your issue is.”
Others shared happier Costco stories. One said a playground that started breaking after a year was fully refunded when the manufacturer would not fix it. Another said their father brought back a hot tub after five to seven years when the original warranty company changed hands and would not honor the coverage, and Costco took it.
His Side Of The Story
The TikToker later sent BroBible a statement. He says he has “always respected Costco” but felt he was wrong about its policy. He describes the TV as a two-year-old LG that “just quit working one day,” and says he took an 86-inch set off his wall to bring it in.
“They informed me they would not refund or exchange my TV and I would need to pay full price for a new one,” he said. He claims his son was yelled at and told to stop recording, and that a second female employee afterward demanded they delete the video.
By his account, he politely declined twice and walked away, then bought a new LG TV at full price anyway.
Why Costco Draws The Line On TVs
Costco’s own website confirms the return policy has limits. It says high-value products like TVs have a strict 90-day return window.
BroBible suggests the reason is that some customers have abused the generosity in the past. It points to a 2023 post on the Costco subreddit in which a store accepted a TV that was originally bought in 2002. Redditors reacted harshly, with one saying, “When Costco stops all returns because of people abusing the generous return policy, everyone point to that guy.”
How To Protect Yourself Before You Buy
You do not have to learn this lesson at the refund counter. A few steps can save you:
- Read the posted return policy and the fine print on the Costco website before you buy a TV or other big electronics.
- Mark the 90-day date on your calendar, and test the set thoroughly during that window.
- Ask about the manufacturer’s warranty or extended coverage at checkout, since the employee in this video said it would have made the difference.
- Keep your receipt and model number handy so you can reach warranty support quickly if something fails.
- Be courteous at the counter. Asking politely, and asking before you film, usually gets better results.
The takeaway for shoppers is plain. Even the most generous return policy has a catch, and the big-ticket items are where the catch usually sits.
More Stories You May Like
- Landlord Rents To A Tenant Who Used Her Cousin’s Info On The Application, Keeps Forgiving Late Rent For Two Years, Then The Tenant Vanishes And Animal Control Calls About What She Left Behind
- Gum Pack Meant To Hold 10 Sticks Now Has A Thumb Grip Where One Stick Used To Be, Cutting The Maker’s Cost By 10% While The Price Stays The Same
- 8 Full-Sized Liquids Travelers Can Actually Bring Through Airport Security In 2026, Including Exemptions Many Passengers Never Hear About

