A supermarket aisle lit by red checkout numbers and a glowing kiosk, the self checkout area where a tip prompt appears.

You scan every item yourself. You bag every item yourself. Then the Walmart self-checkout screen lights up and asks, “Would you like to tip?”

A supermarket aisle lit by red checkout numbers and a glowing kiosk, the self checkout area where a tip prompt appears.

That exact moment is the first scenario put to a man named Larry on the Under the Median channel, and his answer was quick: “No. I would not like to tip because they didn’t do any of the work. We did.”

The hosts say America has “become a tipping culture,” and that it is making it “really hard to know when you actually should tip.” To make the point, they gathered what they call real life tipping stories from their audience and from Reddit, then read them aloud to Larry, who had not seen any of them.

“If You’re Doing All The Work, You Do Not Need To Tip”

The rules of the game were simple. One host reads the scenario, and Larry says whether he would tip, maybe tip, or pass. Everyone at home was invited to play along in the comments.

The second scenario was a self-service food kiosk at an airport. Larry says the key word is self-service: “If you’re doing all the work, you do not need to tip unless you want to tip yourself.”

His co-host pushed the joke further and asked who actually gets the money. Does the kiosk get the tip? Is the kiosk married? Does it have kiosk babies to keep fed and clothed? Behind the laughs sits a real question, which is who ends up with the cash.

Candy Bins, Gas Pumps And A Thrift Store Checkout

Next came a lightning round of five quick scenarios. A candy store let a shopper fill their own bag from the bins, then the employee weighed it and turned the screen around to ask for a tip. Larry’s reply drew a laugh: “No, but he does deserve to be paid.”

A self-serve gas station got the same treatment. Asked if he would tip the pump, Larry said no, joking that you would not want to tip those over because gas could spill everywhere.

The thrift store was the one with some nuance. Larry said he would never tip someone for simply checking him out at a grocery store, a thrift store or any store.

His co-host had a different take. She says many thrift stores are tied to local charities, and if the store made clear a tip was an extra gift supporting its mission, she might be willing. Larry agreed that would “make a little difference.”

“Who Gets The Tip? That’s The Big Thing For Me”

Larry laid out his basic rule. You tip for good service, and sitting down at a restaurant is “a whole other ball of wax.” But if you are doing 90% of the work yourself and still being asked, he wants to know who gets the tip.

If he tips for exceptional service, he says, he wants to be sure that the person who earned it is the one who receives it.

His co-host added a side note for the sit-down crowd. If you are at a really good restaurant getting great service, she says, tip generously, and she believes about 20% of what you paid is the minimum. Larry agreed: “I honestly think 20% is the minimum.”

A Brewery Where Customers Did Everything Except Cook

One scenario came from a couple at a brewery and restaurant. They waited to be seated, then found out they could seat themselves, ordered with a QR code, picked up their own drinks and food, grabbed their own silverware and napkins, and bussed their own table.

Then the payment screen on their phone asked how much they wanted to tip. Larry’s answer was one word: “Zero.” He says he will not tip when he has done most of the work.

The coffee shop scenario was harder to call. A $7 latte, and a tip screen offering three choices: 25%, 35% or 50%.

Larry says he would not tend to tip there, but if he did he would pick the lowest choice, 25%. His co-host noted that the employee may not earn much per hour and might depend on tips for a decent wage, which is something she would weigh before deciding.

Tip The Team For A Dog Bed Bought Online?

Apparently you do not even have to leave the house to be asked. One shopper ordering clothing from Ann Taylor was asked at checkout to tip the team, and another was asked while buying a dog bed online.

Larry says no way. He compared it to shopping on Amazon, where the item goes through a shipper and that is simply their job. The hosts joked that if “the team” meant the store mascot dog was getting extra treats, he might reconsider, and Larry said he would tip if they were giving his dog treats.

The HVAC Visit, The Refrigerator Delivery And A Pre-Added 20%

The hosts stress that they are “absolutely not against tipping” and say they are very good tippers. Their next scenario was an HVAC technician who came for a routine tune-up, stayed 40 minutes, billed $250, and then handed over an iPad with a tip option.

Larry says he does not normally tip the HVAC technician, since the company charges what the job is worth. The couple has a yearly contract for twice-a-year visits, which they say costs less. They did, however, tip the crew that redid their old bathroom, because “they went above and beyond,” and Larry believes that deserves a tip. He says he decides case by case.

Then came what the host called a move from the divine to the ridiculous. A customer paid $150 to have a refrigerator delivered on a holiday and paid extra to have the old one hauled away. The delivery team argued about the haul-away even though the customer had paperwork showing it was paid for, spent 45 minutes calling their bosses, and left grooves in the floor. Standing in front of the damaged floor, they asked for a tip. Larry: “Hands down. No way.”

One more scenario involved takeout from Flanigan’s. The customer checked the charge and found the employee had already added a 20% tip for herself, so the customer refused it, even though they had planned to leave one.

Larry says restaurants are increasingly adding the tip to the bill as if it were tax, and “a tip should be a voluntary thing.” He understands why she refused, since she felt forced, and the host said it is the emotional manipulation that gets people.

The Bottom Line From Australia, Europe And The Comments

The hosts say they heard from an Australian viewer who wrote that they pretty much never tip because employers there are expected to pay workers a decent wage. A viewer from Europe said tipping is much less common where they live, with people rounding up or adding a little for exceptional service.

In the United States, the hosts say, service workers can be paid a very low minimum wage and tips are supposed to make up the rest. A service industry worker in their comments told them she has to split some of her tips with the manager.

They described eating at a restaurant with a sign saying the owner pays workers a good wage, tipping is optional, and the owner takes none of the tips. It cost a little more, the food was really good, they tipped anyway, and they plan to go back.

Larry’s view is that employers who pay their help a good wage will get better help, and customers will get better service because those employees are happy. The hosts closed by asking everyone to share their thoughts on the tipping scenarios in the comments.

More Stories You May Like

+ posts

Similar Posts