Ask a table of relatives which Thanksgiving side dish disappears first, and the answer is rarely the fancy one. For the hosts behind jeffandlaurenshow, it is a humble one pan cornbread pudding.

“My favorite Thanksgiving side dish!” they write. “Easy, delicious and always a crowd favorite.”
View this post on Instagram
Seven Ingredients, And Most Are Already In The Pantry
Here is the full list from the post.
- 1 Jiffy Corn Muffin mix, 8.5 oz box
- 1 can cream corn
- 1 can corn, drained
- 1 stick of butter, melted
- 1 cup sour cream
- 2 eggs
- 1 tablespoon honey
That is it. There is no chopping, no rolling and no special trip to a specialty store.
“Mix All Together” Is The Whole Method
The instructions are as short as the ingredient list. “Mix all together,” they say, then bake at 350 for 45 to 60 minutes until set.
Because everything goes into one bowl and then one pan, cleanup is light. On a day when the oven, the stovetop and every dish in the house are already spoken for, that matters.
Why The Baking Time Runs From 45 To 60 Minutes
The recipe gives a range, and the cue is that the pudding should be “set.” Ovens run differently, and the pan you choose changes how quickly the middle firms up, so the range is a sensible guide rather than a fixed rule.
A common kitchen test is to give the pan a gentle shake near the end. If the center no longer wobbles like liquid, the pudding is ready to come out.
A Spoonable Side That Sits Between Cornbread And Custard
With cream corn, whole corn kernels, sour cream, butter and eggs mixed into a boxed corn muffin mix, the result is a moist, spoonable casserole rather than a dry slice of bread. Many Southern and Midwestern tables have a version of a corn pudding or spoonbread, and this one takes a very easy road to get there.
The honey is only one tablespoon, so it adds a hint of sweetness rather than turning the dish into dessert. That balance is what lets it sit happily next to turkey and gravy.
Plan The Oven Before The Big Day
Thanksgiving oven space is famously tight, and a side that needs 45 to 60 minutes at 350 has to fit into the schedule. Many cooks pull the turkey out to rest and use that window for the sides that bake at a moderate temperature.
Since the recipe bakes at 350, it can often share the oven with other dishes that run at a similar heat. Plan the timing on paper a day ahead, and the family will not be waiting on the pudding while the rest of the meal cools.
Smart Shopping Tips For The Ingredients
Boxed mixes and canned goods are easy to stock early, which takes pressure off a crowded shopping trip. Buying the cans and the Jiffy box a week or two ahead means they are in the cupboard when you need them.
Butter and sour cream are the items worth checking the dates on. Grab fresh ones close to the day, and make sure the eggs are cold and unbroken.
- Check that the muffin mix box is the 8.5 oz size named in the recipe.
- Drain the whole corn well, as the recipe calls for.
- Melt the butter before mixing, so it blends evenly.
What To Serve Alongside It
A soft, buttery corn dish pairs well with something tangy or crisp on the plate. Cranberry sauce, green beans and a simple salad all cut through the richness nicely.
It also makes a good partner for roast turkey or ham, since the pudding soaks up gravy the way a good dressing does. Guests who skip stuffing often go back for a second scoop of this.
Set Up Your Counter Before You Start
Since the recipe is a mix-and-bake job, a little organization makes it nearly effortless. Open the cans and drain the whole corn first, then melt the butter and let it cool slightly before it meets the eggs.
Grease the pan, preheat the oven to 350, and measure the sour cream and honey before you begin. With everything lined up, the actual mixing takes only a few minutes.
Serving And Storing Leftovers Safely
Because this pudding contains eggs and dairy, leftovers deserve some care. The USDA advises refrigerating cooked food within two hours of serving, and reheating leftovers to 165 degrees Fahrenheit before eating.
Cover the pan or move the pudding into a shallow container so it cools quickly. Reheat a portion in the oven or microwave until it is steaming hot all the way through.
Make It Your Own Without Losing The Charm
The beauty of a recipe like this is that it is hard to get wrong. Stick to the seven ingredients as written the first time, and see how the family reacts before you start experimenting.
The couple behind the post call it a crowd favorite, and the shopping list makes it easy to test that claim yourself. One pan, one bowl, one hour at most, and a side dish that might earn a permanent spot on the holiday menu.
More Stories You May Like
- Thanksgiving Dinner For 10 Is Forecast At $78.93 This Year, Down Slightly, But Pumpkin Pie And Gravy Mix Cost More While Cranberries Dropped 6.6%
- Customer Asks Why A $20 Steak And A $100 Steak Get Different Tips When The Waiter Walks The Same Plate, And Why The Mechanic Who Spent Six Hours On His Engine Gets Nothing
- 92-Year-Old Grandma Makes Thanksgiving Sweet Potato Casserole For $11.52 With Eight Big Portions, Then Takes One Bite And Says She Has Never Called A Recipe Perfect Before

