Culver’s Menu Items Customers Argue About Most, Ranked

You know Culver’s menu sparks heated debates every time someone asks what to order, and this article walks you through the items people argue about most. You’ll get a clear sense of which choices divide opinion—burgers, fries, custard, and sandwiches—and why those debates matter when you pick your meal.

Expect quick takes on fan favorites and frequent flashpoints like ButterBurgers, Crinkle Cut Fries, frozen custard, and the grabbag of sandwiches and combos that spark the biggest arguments. The goal is to help you spot the crowd-pleasers and the polarizing picks so you can make smarter orders every visit.

ButterBurger Cheese

You’ll recognize this as Culver’s most ordered ButterBurger variation — melted cheese on a toasted, buttered bun. It’s simple but reliably satisfying, especially if you favor a classic cheeseburger flavor.

Expect a soft, buttery roll and a thin, well-seasoned patty that stays juicy. Fans argue over cheese type and cook level, but most agree the combo hits the comfort-food mark.

Try it with crinkle-cut fries or a concrete for a Midwest-style meal. For menu context, Culver’s highlights this as a signature item on their site (https://www.culvers.com/).

Original ButterBurger

You’ll find the Original ButterBurger as the baseline of most debates—simple, toasted buttered bun and a fresh beef patty that leans on quality over bells and whistles.

If you like a straightforward, unadorned burger you’ll appreciate how toppings don’t overpower the meat.

Fans praise its balance and made-to-order feel, while critics call it plain; that split keeps it on many “must-try vs skip” lists, including rankings of Culver’s burgers and menu items.

Crinkle Cut Fries

You’ll see people split on Culver’s crinkle cut fries: some call them reliably crispy, others say they’re forgettable.
They’re cooked to order and meant to be golden and fluffy inside, which you can read about on Culver’s official Crinkle Cut Fries page.

If you like thicker, ridged fries that hold salt and dip, these might be your go-to.
But if you prefer shoestring crispness, you’ll probably skip them next time.

Fresh Frozen Custard

You’ll find Culver’s fresh frozen custard is richer and denser than typical soft-serve, which sparks strong opinions depending on how much creaminess you want.
Fans praise its texture and the Concrete Mixer® mix-ins, while others prefer lighter, icier desserts.

If you like thick, custardy shakes or sundaes, this will likely hit the mark for you.
Check current menu options and flavors at Culver’s website for what’s available near you.

ButterBurger Single vs Double

You’ll notice the single feels lighter and lets the beef flavor stand out more. It’s easier to finish and pairs well with a side if you want balance.

The double gives you more beef and a meatier bite, which some people prefer for value and satisfaction. Expect a heavier mouthfeel and more grease on the bun.

If you choose a single, toppings matter more. With a double, the patties often become the main attraction.

Chicken Tenders

You’ll find Culver’s chicken tenders split opinions because they can taste like real white meat but sometimes come across as processed.
Some diners praise the size and seasoning, while others say they lack the crispness and freshness they expect.

If you want to read a roundup comparing fast-food tenders, check this ranking of chicken tenders for context.

Grilled Reuben Melt

You’ll notice opinions split the moment you mention the Grilled Reuben Melt. Some love the tang of sauerkraut and Thousand Island against melted Swiss; others say the corned beef portion feels skimpy.

The sandwich uses grilled rye and classic Reuben components, so if you like bold, vinegary flavors you’ll probably enjoy it. Try it once to decide—reviews and the official Culver’s menu describe it the same way.

ButterBurger Combo Meals

You’ll see debates about which combo gives the best value: single, double, or triple ButterBurger with fries and a drink.
Pick a single if you want something lighter; the double or triple stacks up if you’re sharing or very hungry.

Sides and drink choices shape the combo experience. Try crinkle-cut fries if you like classic texture, or swap for a salad to cut calories.
Check the menu when you order—regional items and limited-time adds can change what comes with a combo.

Fried Pork Loin Sandwich

You’ll find the Fried Pork Loin Sandwich either loved or dismissed by regulars.
It uses a center-cut pork loin, hand-breaded and fried, served on a toasted bun; quality can vary by location.

If you want more flavor, ask for toppings or extra condiments.
Some reviewers call it bland compared to regional tenderloins, while others appreciate its crunchy breading and simple profile.

Try it once with pickles and mayo to see which side you fall on.
More about the sandwich appears on Culver’s menu page.

ButterBurger No Bun (Lettuce Wrap)

If you skip the bun, you still get Culver’s signature beef and buttery flavors, but with fewer carbs.
Some fans say the lettuce wrap keeps the burger light and lets the patty stand out.

You might miss the toasted bun’s texture, though; the wrap can feel flimsy during the meal.
Ask for extra lettuce or napkins if you plan to eat it on the go.

Want a compromise? Try it once to see if the cleaner bite fits your taste.

 

More from Cultivated Comfort:

• 7 Vintage Home Items From the ’60s That Are Collectors’ Dream Finds
• 7 Vintage Home Goods That Became Collectors’ Gold
• 7 Fast-Food Chains That Changed for the Worse
• 7 Frozen Dinners That Were Better Back in the Day