Nineteen dollars. For one taco. That is the top price for a taco at the New York outpost of El Califa de Leon, the taqueria whose original Mexico City location earned a Michelin star. And according to one diner who went to see for himself, the opening has not exactly been a smooth ride.
The diner behind the YouTube channel @Jamesnu took a look at the new spot, and he started with the facts that make this story such a conversation piece. The Mexico City original held its Michelin star for two years. This year, it lost it. Now the name is on a restaurant in New York, with tacos priced at as much as $19 each.
It is the kind of setup that makes people stop mid-scroll. A taco is supposed to be the easy, cheap, handheld meal. Seeing a price tag like that next to it feels like a dare.
A rough start, according to the reviews
Before he sat down to eat, the diner did some homework. He read through the Google reviews for the New York restaurant on the day he went, and his takeaway was that it “doesn’t seem to have had the smoothest start.” That is a careful way of putting it, and it is worth noting what he did and did not say. He was describing what the reviews suggested, not announcing a final judgment on the place.
He then went to the restaurant and dined there that evening, so he was reporting on the experience in person. What we can say from here is that the question hanging over the restaurant is a fair one: is a name with a Michelin star in its past worth a price like that?
What a Michelin star does and does not tell you
A Michelin star is awarded by the Michelin Guide, and it is meant to recognize the cooking at a specific restaurant. That last part is the key. A star belongs to a particular kitchen in a particular place. When a famous restaurant opens a second location in another city, the new location is a different kitchen that has to prove itself on its own.
It also helps to remember that a star is not forever. In this case the original earned its star, held it for two years and then lost it. That does not make the Mexico City taqueria a bad place to eat. It does mean the reputation is something a restaurant has to keep earning.
How to decide if a pricey meal is worth it
Whether you are eyeing this taco counter or any buzzy new place in your own town, a few simple habits can protect your wallet.
- Read the recent reviews, not the old ones. A restaurant in its first weeks can look very different from one a few months in. Sort by newest and see what people are saying now.
- Look for patterns, not one-off complaints. One unhappy reviewer might have caught a bad night. When many reviews mention the same problem, take it seriously.
- Do the math before you order. If a single item is priced far above what you would normally pay, think about how many you would need to feel full, and what the total would be.
- Start small. Order one or two items to taste before committing to a full meal. If it is great, you can always order more.
- Give new places a little time. Many new restaurants need a few weeks to find their rhythm, and waiting can mean a better meal.
- Decide what you are paying for. A famous name, a fancy room and great food are three different things. Know which one you are after.
There is also no shame in the simplest strategy of all. If the price makes your jaw drop, you are allowed to walk away and find a taco you love for a lot less. Great tacos are not rare, and the best ones are often at small counters and trucks with a line out the door.
It also helps to know your own tolerance. Some people happily pay extra for a night out at a place everyone is talking about, and that is a perfectly good reason to spend money. Others would rather put the same amount toward several meals. Neither choice is wrong. The trouble starts when your expectations and the price do not match. Decide what you want from the night before you walk in and the bill stings a lot less.
The bottom line
El Califa de Leon in New York is a story about hype meeting reality. The original in Mexico City earned a Michelin star, kept it for two years and lost it this year. The New York location arrived with that famous name and tacos priced as high as $19 each, and early reviews suggested a bumpy opening. What matters now is whether the food justifies the bill.
If you are tempted to try it, go in with open eyes. Check the newest reviews, order a little at a time and decide for yourself whether a famous taco is worth a famous price. Your own taste buds, and your own budget, get the final say.
More Stories You May Like
- Grandma Faced Her Fear of Flying for the First Time in 15 Years and Her Family Cheered Her All the Way Onto the Plane
- Hibachi Chef Sees the Most Expensive Hibachi in New York and Says Too Much Butter and Burnt Scallops Are Not Worth That Price
- Grandpa Turned 100 and Heard His Family Say Surprise We Are Taking You to Hawaii and He Showed Up on the Plane in His Best Hawaiian Shirt
