13 Costco Bakery Items Worth the Hype

As a hub for bulk-buy bargains and unexpected food finds, Costco’s bakery section is becoming increasingly popular among savvy shoppers. From gourmet cakes to artisan breads, these treats are not just delicious, but also incredible value for money. If you’re not yet a convert, it’s high time to discover the hype.

This list of 13 must-try items from Costco’s bakery is based on real-world trends, expert recommendations, and customer reviews. It delivers a comprehensive guide to the best the bakery has to offer. Whether you’re a long-standing member or considering a Costco membership, here’s a sneak peek into what you can expect from this treasure trove of baked goods.

1. All American Chocolate Cake

Costco’s All American Chocolate Cake is a decadent delight that chocolate lovers can’t resist. Weighing in at a whopping seven pounds, this rich, multi-layered cake is frosted with chocolate shavings and is big enough to serve a crowd. It’s the perfect centerpiece for any celebration and is often overlooked due to its size.

With more people opting to entertain at home, this cake has become a hot item. It offers value for money, with a single purchase serving up to 20 people. Plus, it’s a surefire crowd-pleaser. And according to this Business Insider review, it’s one of the best cakes you can buy from Costco.

2. Apple Pie

Costco’s Apple Pie is a classic favorite that never disappoints. Made with sweet, crisp apples and a flaky crust, this pie is pure comfort food. It’s a perennial favorite that customers buy regularly, but it’s often overlooked in favor of more exotic dessert options.

The current trend of nostalgia and comfort baking has brought this traditional dessert back into the spotlight. With its generous size and classic taste, Costco’s Apple Pie offers incredible value. As this Food & Wine article states, it’s a worthy contender among store-bought pies.

3. Kirkland Signature Artisan Rolls

The Kirkland Signature Artisan Rolls are a staple item in many Costco shopping carts. Made with a blend of enriched wheat, malted barley flour, and real honey, these rolls have a soft, chewy texture and a slightly sweet flavor. Despite their simplicity, these rolls are often overlooked in favor of more unique bakery offerings.

With a recent surge in home cooking and dining, these versatile rolls are gaining popularity. They’re perfect for sandwiches, dinner rolls, or even just a snack. The Business Insider recommends them as a top food product from Costco due to their taste and value.

4. Croissants

Costco’s croissants are a bakery item that most customers don’t pass up. These buttery, flaky pastries are made using traditional French methods, resulting in a croissant that’s as good as you’d find in a Parisian bakery. Despite their quality, these croissants are often overlooked because of their plain appearance compared to other pastries.

The ongoing trend of at-home brunches and breakfasts has boosted the popularity of these croissants. They offer excellent value and the convenience of a ready-made breakfast or snack. Delish calls them a must-buy item from Costco.

5. Cinnamon Pull-A-Part

The Cinnamon Pull-A-Part from Costco’s bakery is a sweet, sticky treat that’s perfect for breakfast or dessert. Made from layers of dough and cinnamon sugar, this pastry is a favorite among customers for its delicious taste and satisfying texture. Despite its popularity, it’s often overlooked due to its unassuming appearance.

This pastry is gaining attention as more people seek out comforting, homemade-style baked goods. Its value for money and delicious taste make it a great choice for families or gatherings. According to this Eat This, Not That! review, it’s a bakery item worth trying.

6. Danish Variety Pack

The Danish Variety Pack from Costco offers a selection of fruit and cheese-filled pastries. Each pack contains four different flavors: apple, cherry, cheese, and cinnamon. These soft, sweet Danishes are often kept in regular rotation by Costco shoppers, but others may overlook them in favor of more familiar bakery items.

As variety packs become increasingly popular, this Danish assortment is a trendy choice. It offers great value, providing a mix of flavors to suit everyone’s tastes. According to CheatSheet, it’s one of the best items you can buy at the Costco bakery.

7. Organic Ancient Grain Bread

Costco’s Organic Ancient Grain Bread is a nutrient-dense option for health-conscious shoppers. Made with a mix of organic grains including quinoa, spelt, and millet, this bread offers a robust flavor and hearty texture. While it’s a staple for some, it may be overlooked by those who prefer traditional white or whole wheat bread.

With the rise of organic and health-focused food trends, this bread is gaining popularity. It’s an excellent value, offering high-quality ingredients at a reasonable price. This Organic Authority article highlights it as a top organic choice at Costco.

8. Tuxedo Cake

The Tuxedo Cake from Costco’s bakery is a luxurious dessert that’s sure to impress. This multi-layered cake features creamy mousse, rich chocolate cake, and a glossy ganache topping. Despite its gourmet appeal, it’s often overlooked due to its higher price point compared to other Costco cakes.

As consumers continue to seek out quality, restaurant-style desserts at home, this cake is gaining attention. It offers excellent value, serving up to 12 people for a fraction of the cost of a similar cake from a bakery. Delish recommends it as a must-try for chocolate lovers.

9. Butter Croissants

The Butter Croissants from Costco are a bakery item that consistently pleases. Made with real butter and a traditional French recipe, these croissants are flaky, tender, and full of flavor. However, many shoppers overlook these pastries in favor of the bakery’s more unique offerings.

As more people embrace the art of at-home brunching and breakfasting, these buttery delights are in the spotlight. They offer incredible value, allowing you to enjoy a high-quality breakfast or snack at a fraction of the cost of a bakery. Mashed lists them among the best bakery items at Costco.

10. Bagel Variety Pack

The Bagel Variety Pack from Costco offers a selection of four different flavors: plain, everything, cinnamon raisin, and blueberry. These bagels are soft, chewy, and perfect for a quick breakfast or lunch. While they’re a favorite among many Costco shoppers, they may be overlooked by those who prefer more unique bakery items.

With the current trend of variety and convenience in food, this bagel pack is a popular choice. It offers great value, providing a mix of flavors to suit everyone’s tastes. According to Eat This, Not That!, it’s a bakery item worth trying.