Niagara Falls cascading over the edge under a hazy sky

Picture a flaky pastry crust holding a thick layer of vanilla ice cream, then a frozen pumpkin cream layer, then a cloud of fresh whipped cream, with warm maple syrup running down over everything. That pie was a signature dessert at a Niagara Falls restaurant that has been gone for years.

Niagara Falls cascading over the edge under a hazy sky

The place was John’s Flaming Hearth. For more than five decades, people from all over the world came through its doors, and while many were tourists, it was the locals who came back again and again to celebrate a special night out.

Home cook Rene of Kitchen in the Shire says that when she went looking for the memories people still have of the restaurant, one thing kept coming up in conversation: the pie. She found an old recipe published under the John’s Flaming Hearth name, used it as her starting point, and made a few tweaks of her own along the way.

The Honeymoon Capital Restaurant Served Its Final Meal In February 2006

Rene explains that newlyweds have been traveling to Niagara Falls for generations, so many that the city became known as the honeymoon capital of the world. With the magnificent waterfalls, the hotels and the restaurants, it is easy to understand why. In 1954, a man named John saw an opportunity there and bought a restaurant on Military Road.

In February 2006, after more than 50 years of welcoming tourists, foreign dignitaries and families celebrating special occasions, John’s Flaming Hearth served its final meal. Chef Paul Bunts, who sent out that last dinner, said it felt like the end of an era.

That was not the end of the pumpkin ice cream pie, though. According to a newspaper account Rene found, John went to work at another place in Niagara Falls after his restaurant closed, and his pie went with him.

The Pie Followed Its Maker To The Polish Nook, Where It Still Ends The Meal

The new home was the Polish Nook, which Stanley and Stella opened in 1964. By the time John arrived, it was only open for special events, and he helped bring back regular dinner service.

The restaurant is still going strong today. The third generation of the family now runs it, and they still serve Stella’s original Polish recipes, including homemade perogi, stuffed cabbage and pork chops. Order the Polish platter and you get something special to close out the meal: a slice of that pumpkin ice cream pie.

A Thin Layer Of Chocolate Is The Secret Surprise Hiding Under The Ice Cream

Rene starts by melting about 65 grams of chocolate over medium low heat. It does not need to be boiling hot, just smooth and melted, and low enough that nothing burns to the bottom of the pan.

She uses a pre-baked crust in a 9 inch deep dish pan, and says any crust you like will do. Because the next layer is a wetter one, she brushes a very thin coat of chocolate over the whole crust as a barrier. It hardens up and keeps the crust a little crunchier, which she likes. Into the freezer it goes for about 10 minutes.

Next comes a quart of vanilla ice cream that has softened on the counter for about 10 minutes. Rene scoops it into the pie and spreads it evenly against the chocolate layer, taking care not to press it down tight. She holds onto the crust while she works, since a pre-baked crust wiggles around in the pan. A few cracks in the crust do not worry her, because the filling freezes right away. Then the pie goes back into the freezer for half an hour to 45 minutes.

Cooking Down The Pumpkin Brings Out Flavor, And The Spices Bloom In The Hot Pan

While the ice cream firms up, Rene puts pumpkin in a pan on medium low heat. Pumpkin holds quite a bit of water, so she reduces it by about 55 grams, roughly a third to a half cup, to concentrate the flavor. She weighed it as she went, and it took about 8 to 8 and a half minutes. Without a scale, she suggests somewhere between 7 and a half and 8 and a half minutes.

She keeps the pumpkin moving so it does not burn on the bottom, and she listens closely. A drying sound is normal, she says, but it can turn into a burning sound quickly. In the last few seconds she stirs in a little clove, cinnamon, ginger and nutmeg to bloom the spices in the hot pumpkin. Her reaction: “Oh my word, the smell. It’s like heaven.”

She moves the pumpkin to a metal bowl, stirs in a little salt and sugar, and lets the heat dissolve the sugar. After a few minutes she stirs again, spreads it thin in the bowl, covers it and chills it in the refrigerator until it is cold.

A Homemade Whipped Cream Canister Tops The Whole Thing Off

Rene whips heavy cream in a cold bowl to stiff peaks. She stirs about a third into the cooled pumpkin to loosen it, then gently folds in the rest from the side and up through the middle until the dark streaks disappear, taking care not to squish the air out.

For the topping, she brought out a gadget she bought the day before, an Isi whipper that makes canned style whipped cream from your own ingredients. She says she is “ridiculously excited” about it. Into it go a cup of heavy cream, about 3 tablespoons of confectioners’ sugar, a tiny pinch of salt and half a teaspoon of her homemade vanilla, then a nitrous oxide cartridge. She screws it on until she hears the sound, shakes it and chills it.

The pumpkin cream goes onto the pie in a few blobs and is spread out to cover the chocolate, leaving the crust showing and a little mound in the middle. Rene says the chocolate is a surprise. If you like, you can make the pie the day before and let it sit out 10 to 15 minutes before cutting. She gave hers about four hours in the freezer.

“I Now Understand Why This Pie Is So Popular”

Cutting day did not go perfectly. Rene pushed too hard with her knife and broke the crust off, which she cheerfully blamed on herself, “my fault, not the pie’s fault,” and managed to put it back together. When the whipped cream glopped down the side, she shrugged: “I guess you can’t ever have enough whipped cream.”

Then came the maple drizzle, and then the first bite. She says the pumpkin is “like a creme brulee smooth,” and that the ice cream somehow feels colder than the pumpkin, which makes no sense but works. “I now understand why this pie is so popular,” she says. “I highly recommend this pie. It’s not difficult to make.”

Smart Habits For Making A Frozen Pie At Home

Frozen pies reward patience. Chilling each layer before adding the next keeps the layers neat, which is why Rene’s slice showed even bands of color. A knife dipped in warm water and wiped dry between cuts glides through a frozen dessert far more cleanly than a cold one.

The chocolate trick is worth borrowing for other pies too. A thin brushed layer on a baked crust works as a moisture barrier for any soft or creamy filling, and it adds a little flavor of its own.

When you fold whipped cream into something heavier, loosen the base first with a spoonful, then fold the rest in gently. Stirring hard knocks out the air, and the air is what gives the pie its lift. Chilling the bowl before whipping cream also helps it reach stiff peaks faster.

If you are making this ahead for a holiday table, the freezer does the work for you. Rene has two questions for her readers: what is your favorite pie, and have you ever been to Niagara Falls? Whatever your answer, a slice of this one makes a fine reason to remember a restaurant that served generations of couples and families.

More Stories You May Like

+ posts

Similar Posts